Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

El Capitan and non Apple SSD drives using TRIM

I've been a Mac user since the first Mac came on the market. I've had just about every major update in hardware and software since the beginning. On my 2009 Mac Pro with everything updated except the CPU I added a non Apple SSD. I utilized the freeware for TRIM to make it work and it was great. I loved the added speed! No real problems with Maverick. But then I made the mistake of upgrading earlier to Yosemite than I usually do for my Mac's. The problems began occurring in a bewildering ways. Multiple calls with hours long tech support with multiple Apple Techs we looked at every possible cause and believe me everyone was stumped! Then on my own I found the answer and that was that Yosemite did not include the necessary bit of code that allowed the freeware for TRIM to function. I have been told that later versions of Yosemite did have the missing code added.


Now, I want to KNOW before I upgrade to El Capitan if it has the full set of code that would disable the non-Apple SSD?

OS X Yosemite (10.10.1), MacPro 4.1

Posted on Oct 2, 2015 5:05 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Oct 2, 2015 8:20 PM

Non-Apple TRIM Enabler is no longer needed. Apple has relented and put in a way to enable TRIM on Third-party drives. It is subject to manual enabling, and when you do, you agree to the massive disclaimer shown in this article:

http://9to5mac.com/2015/06/12/os-x-ssd-trim-support-el-capitan/


.

12 replies

Oct 4, 2015 12:39 PM in response to rerailer24k

Sorry If I missed something, but I would like to ask whether I can safely enable TRIM on my new SSD drive. I have upgraded my MBP Late 2011 with new Samsung EVO 850 drive, and did not find any clear confirmation that it is safe/recommended to enable it under El Capitan.


I understand the benefits of TRIM and I am definitely for using it, but there is the "Crucial" thing (that it should not be enabled on some Crucial drives - and this is NOT my case since I have Samsung), and also there is this massive Warning disclaimer.


So, is anyone there with working, real-life example of using Samsung drive while having TRIM enabled, under El Capitan?


Of course, everyone will tell me "you have been warned", but I also understand that Apple must warn users in these disclaimers...


Thanks for help!

Oct 4, 2015 12:57 PM in response to rerailer24k

Actually it seems that the pundits of TRIM are getting less and less as

drive manufacturers get improved controllers with better and more efficient

garbage collection, wear leveling, etc.


TRIM was actually available on the very last Yosemite release and I had tried

it for a while on my Macbook Pro and really saw no change, actual or perceived.

The drive was a Kingston SSDNow v300 which Kingston was claiming also that

they really didn't need it.

Oct 4, 2015 1:13 PM in response to woodmeister50

and really saw no change, actual or perceived.


TRIM will generally NOT cause a contemporaneous performance increase, and that is as expected. The use of TRIM on an ongoing or occasional scrubbing basis reduces the likelihood that you will get into a diabolical near-race condition.


This condition is where the drive shows LOTS of free space under Mac OS X, but that free space is fragmented. The drive does not have enough empty Superblocks available for Fast Writes. This can cause performance to degrade very suddenly and quite substantially, and can cause the drive to stop working entirely. Although this condition is rare, it is extremely ugly to have it happen.


--------


Pundits are getting less vociferous because TRIM has become generally available, not because its need has been reduced or eliminated.

Oct 5, 2015 1:41 PM in response to Grant Bennet-Alder

Yes, that is the reason why I wonder If I can safely enable it. I don't expect any performance gain, all I need for the drive is its longevity and safety. My previous original 120 GB SSD from Apple (Toshiba) had about 5 - 10 GB of free space in the last 2 years, and I was really struggling keeping that space available.


When I cloned the drive to the new one, I discovered that only about 90 GB of data was transferred, and while some space was occupied by the Recovery partition, I considered the missing space was destroyed/wasted by the dying SSD cells (as this tiny remaining space was constantly being overwritten).


Now I have 100 GB of free space, but I want to give the drive the best treatment, so should I go for TRIM, any vote up or recommendation? Thanks guys!

Oct 5, 2015 2:30 PM in response to Durandall

Don't you love when you come to a forum for a straight answer and everyone chimes in giving you useless info and their opinions?



Short answer: YES - you can (and should) enable built in trim now


in terminal type:


sudo trimforce enable

(then enter password)


It will prompt you for a reboot, so make sure you're not doing anything important at the time you try this. Also, remove any third party trim enabler patch too!

El Capitan and non Apple SSD drives using TRIM

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.