Hi all,
I have been keeping an eye on this thread and several others regarding the frozen UI except for mouse. This has been happening with my late 2009 i7 iMac since OS 10.9.
I have run Apple's hardware test several times, the latest being on a very very hot day (+30 degrees C in the room). This was the extended test and the Mac passed with flying colours. This was due to the remarks that it may be a GPU or RAM issue. The HDD was replaced last year (out of warranty) as the Seagate failed. The Genius store checked the machine, gave it a good clean and said no hardware issues detected.
I rebuild my machine once every few months (for no good reason other than playing around) and this issue always randomly crops up. Current build is 10.11.4 installed using a USB key (10.11.0) then running software update.
The issue occurred about an hour ago. The same message as always with 10.10 and 10.11 - WindowsServer reported as unresponsive by watchdog daemon. Interestingly, this message used to be a GPU panic under 10.9 - exact same symptoms. Mouse moves, keyboard caps lock led toggles the OS keeps running in the background but no UI. Requires forced 5 second power toggle. Today is a very cool day so there is no way the GPU could have gotten hot.
Now, some things I have noted that gel with this thread. This always happens using Safari only. I can use any other software and the machine runs just fine, including GPU hungry resource hogs. It did not seem to happen at all when Flash was not installed (which I have just done) but I can not confirm this other than a prolonged test without Flash. Whether this is a Flash / Safari issue our not needs to be confirmed.
Might I have a stab as to suspect that people having this issue have Macs with ATI Radeon cards in them? Mine is the 512Mb 4850. Could there be a code deadlock with the ATI drivers and Flash / Safari?
The fact that this has been happening for so many years with my machine tells me the underlying problem has existed since 10.9. However, the randomness is confounding. I can go for weeks of intensive (with Flash installed) with no issue, then bang several freezes within a few days.
A.
---
PS - I just remembered that a few weeks ago during +30 degree C weather I was manipulating large photos using Pixelmator for something like 3 hours with the fans slowing spooling up to high speed. These were very large images. The screen went blank completely for about 10 minutes then returned to normal. Interestingly there was no error logged and the system was running just fine in the background. I suspect this was the GPU gracefully shutting down due to heat to save it's bacon. I continued slowly and the issue did not occur again. This to me tells me that the GPU is engineered to cool itself if it detects it is getting too hot. I really don't think this mouse cursor moving / UI freeze is heat related......