Yosemite: Website Using Wrong Certificate

Hi all,

I currently have three websites hosting on Server (5.0). For simplicity's sake, let's call them Red.com, Blue.com, and Green.com.

I have verified SSL certificates for all three domains with valid trust chains. I imported all three certificates correctly under "Certificates."

Now, under websites, for Red.com, Blue.com, and Green.com, I set each site to use it's corresponding SSL certificate.

However, all three websites are using the certificate for Blue.com, despite what their setting is under Websites, and is causing validation issues on the browser end. The only reason I can think of is that under "Certificates" in the side pane, the certificate for Blue.com is listed first, so all SSL-websites default to that one despite what's configured under websites? I've tried deleting the website profile for Green.com and Red.com and rebuilding them from scratch, selecting the Green.com and Red.com certificate, but once I go to the websites in a browser a certificate warning pops up and shows that it's trying to use Blue.com's certificate.

Can anyone help with this?

EDIT: I should note that this is only a problem if I have IP Address set to 'Any.' If I use the IP address in the drop down (the server's IP) it pulls the valid certificate, but setting the IP prevents me from using profile manager and other services.