LIZ BUCHER wrote:
On another note: SMART Utility showed my HD is failing. However today I ran EtreCheck and it did not show a problem with the HD. Which should I believe? I'm only doing this because I've been having crashes for a few months and they are getting more frequent. I increased memory from 4 to 8GB, made no difference. I'll post this in a separate thread on your suggestion. Thanks again.
Hello LIZ,
EtreCheck, like any similar tool, only reports failures if it encounters an some specific indicator of failure. Those indicators are based on other software and sensors and they may come and go. If any tool proclaims your hard drive to have physically failed, then you should believe it. Even if you run it again and you don't see the failure, you should still replace the drive. The old mechanical hard drives in notebook computers tend to fail after 2-3 years. If this is your original hard drive, you are well past that. Before I switched to SSD drives, I used to replace my drives every 2 years whether they needed it or not. SSDs are supposed to last from 7-20 years. Generally, if you aren't happy with the performance of your computer, it is 5 years old, and has the original, mechanical hard drive, I will pretty much always recommend upgrading to an SSD. The backup, update, restore process will help to clean things up and the SSD experience will be a dramatic and noticeable improvement. An SSD itself is 100 times faster than a mechanical hard drive and will make your machine about 4 times faster overall.
However, I looked at your other posts and I'm very suspicious of the SMART utility you downloaded. I strongly suspect all you really downloaded was adware. While I'm sure an SSD will make your machine run super fast, I think you probably have other issues to fix before taking a hardware upgrade and restore. I suggest starting a new thread, describing the problems you have an in as much detail as possible, and include an EtreCheck report with default settings. EtreCheck includes the results of the operating system's own SMART status. If it was failing, I would expect EtreCheck to report that too. Considering the fact that your SMART utility is a 3rd party tool downloaded from a known adware site, I don't necessarily believe it. Don't get me wrong, an SSD will definitely improve things. But I sincerely think you have other problems to be looked at first.