Concerning using two drives in a MacBook Pro

I have installed a new SSD and placed the old Hard Drive in the Optical Bay. Prior to that, I had cloned the disk to the SSD. Now and after installation, the only thing is that when I boot from the SSD, the computer still shows the SSD start up disk as device in the side bar while the old hard drive is shown in the sidebar as the main Hard drive. It is obvious that the active disk, system are used from the SSD though. The Terminal starts from the name of the old disk even though it lists the contents of the Applications on the SSD when I ls.

Now, I wanted to erase the old HDD while booted in SSD. Disk Utility cannot unmount the disk, it says and quit the reformatting task. I tried the Recovery Hd too, the same result.

Now my questions are :

1. Do we have a conflict at the level of structure somewhere? A permanent link or what si it I am missing?

2. Can I safely erase, reformat the old hard drive and will the finder finds its path to the structure on the SSD?

Or what is I have missed?

I am on Lion (10.7.5).

MacBookPro 15-inch, early 2011

Grateful for your feedback or any suggestion.

MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.5.8)

Posted on Nov 21, 2015 8:56 PM

Reply
14 replies

Nov 21, 2015 9:24 PM in response to DMD65

If you cloned the old drive to the SSD, the spotlight index on the SSD probably points to all the items on the old drive. You probably should force spotlight to reindex the drives.


Also... if you haven't done it already, rename one of the drives so they do not have the same name.


You can erase the old drive. It wouldn't be any different than if you cloned the drive and then never used the old drive again.

Nov 21, 2015 10:56 PM in response to DMD65

Now I re-selected the SSD as the start up because it crossed my mind that I had selected but left the window unlocked and that maybe have some significance. I locked it and I erased the Hdd successfully.

However, the sidebar shows this hierarchy:

the device on the top is the name of my old Hard drive. I am sure I am missing something here.

User uploaded file

Nov 22, 2015 6:24 AM in response to DMD65

DMD65 wrote:


Now I re-selected the SSD as the start up because it crossed my mind that I had selected but left the window unlocked and that maybe have some significance. I locked it and I erased the Hdd successfully.

However, the sidebar shows this hierarchy:

the device on the top is the name of my old Hard drive. I am sure I am missing something here.

User uploaded file


Is "DMD1" the name that you are concerned about? It is the name of your MacBook Pro. To change that, visit System Preferences -> Sharing.

Nov 22, 2015 7:03 AM in response to Duane

Dear Duane, thank you. I know. Actually I wrote my reply too fast but couldn't edit or delete it for some reason, that is why I sent another reply asking to ignore that point.

In fact, everything works really fine. I have new questions about other things, for instance, if I can place the ~/Library on the second disk with a symbolic link on the start up disk, but it is perhaps more appropriate to ask this question in a separate post.

So far at the beginning, it is fast and my MBP has got a new life. The stability of SSD, compared to HD,remains to be examined…

Nov 22, 2015 7:36 AM in response to Duane

I read about SSD being sensitive to much writing and re-writing. Library contains files that are often modified (specially Mail is a good candidate), so I figured out it'd better to add Library or at least ~/Library/Mail to the HDD and create a link (Alias) on the SSD. This said, Library in the Home folder has some new features in terms of permissions (it is since Lion invisible if you don't change the flagging). So I am unsure if this is a good idea. Any suggestion?

Nov 22, 2015 8:21 AM in response to DMD65

This is completely opposite logic as to why you should install an SSD. The reason to install an SSD is to make things read/write faster than when using a HD. If you put the most frequently accessed/modified on a HD you are negating the advantage of the SSD.


Realize that Apple is installing SSD drives in their laptop and no HD. This is because there is no problem reading and writing often to the SSD.

Nov 22, 2015 8:54 AM in response to Duane

On this point you seem to be right and I misled by some excessive cautious attitude towards a technology that is still relatively new (mass implementation is not longer than three years and the new and more voluminous ones, like mine (500gb), are even newer). I just want to treat it in a way that doesn't wear it off too fast. But my concerns are admittedly illogical. What else should I then think about using Solid State compared to a HDD? What about TRIM and what about fragmentation?

Nov 22, 2015 7:23 PM in response to Duane

Dear Duane

Thanks for your reply.

For SSD and the issue of writing and re-writing, I quote Wikipedia (perhaps not the most reliable reference and it is a quite general statement):

"An SSD write operation can be done on a single page but, due to hardware limitations, erase commands always affect entire blocks;[10] consequently writing data to empty pages on an SSD is very fast, but slows down considerably once previously written pages need to be overwritten."


The same source says the following about TRIM:

"Although the AHCI block device driver gained the ability to display whether a device supports the Trim operation in 10.6.6 (10J3210),[32] the functionality itself remained inaccessible until 10.6.8, when the Trim operation was exposed via the IOStorageFamily and filesystem (HFS+) support was added.[citation needed] Until 10.10.4, Mac OS X natively enabled Trim only for Apple-branded SSDs; third-party utilities are available to enable it for other brands. Old third party TRIM drivers stopped working as of the Yosemite update.[33] Updated drivers now exist that work with OS X Yosemite.[34][35] In Mac OS X update 10.10.4, Apple added a command line utility, trimforce, that can be used to enable TRIM on third-party SSDs"

I am working in Lion (10.7.5), and the quotation seems to support what you are saying even though the information provided is too brief and sketchy.


Couldn't find much Macosx specific information on the net about fragmentation.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Concerning using two drives in a MacBook Pro

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.