Server 5 not logging AFP activity and errors

Here is a new one:

I am running Server 5.0.15 on OS X 10.10.5. I have previously enabled both activity and error logging for AFP service, and logging was working up until recently. I had a situation that led me to look at the logs, and found that the activity and logs we not being recorded. I double checked my AFP settings and everything looks good. Both my activity log and error log are set to "yes".

I thought there may be an issue with the log files, so I recreated the log files, and still no luck. Does anyone have any ideas on what I can try to get these logs running again?

afp:maxGuests = -1

afp:afpTCPPort = 548

afp:clientSleepTime = 24

afp:replyCacheQuantum = 32

afp:maxConnections = -1

afp:sendGreetingOnce = no

afp:reconnectTTLInMin = 1440

afp:clientSleepOnOff = yes

afp:loginGreeting = ""

afp:errorLogPath = "“/Library/Logs/AppleFileService/AppleFileServiceError.log”"

afp:errorLogTime = 14

afp:activityLogTime = 14

afp:errorLogSize = 1000

afp:kerberosPrincipal = (REMOVED)

afp:recon1SrvrKeyTTLHrs = 168

afp:idleDisconnectOnOff = no

afp:reconnectFlag = "no_admin_kills"

afp:activityLog = yes

afp:reconnectKeyLocation = "/private/etc/AFP.conf"

afp:loginGreetingTime = 0

afp:adminGetsSp = yes

afp:fullServerMode = yes

afp:idleDisconnectMsg = ""

afp:updateHomeDirQuota = yes

afp:activityLogPath = "“/Library/Logs/AppleFileService/AppleFileServiceAccess.log”"

afp:authenticationMode = "standard_and_kerberos"

afp:admin31GetsSp = no

afp:shutdownThreshold = 3

afp:TCPQuantum = 1048576

afp:allowSendMessage = yes

afp:idleDisconnectTime = 10

afp:loggingAttributes:logOpenFork = yes

afp:loggingAttributes:logDelete = yes

afp:loggingAttributes:logCreateDir = yes

afp:loggingAttributes:logLogin = yes

afp:loggingAttributes:logLogout = yes

afp:loggingAttributes:logCreateFile = yes

afp:tickleTime = 30

afp:specialAdminPrivs = no

afp:noNetworkUsers = no

afp:idleDisconnectFlag:adminUsers = yes

afp:idleDisconnectFlag:registeredUsers = yes

afp:idleDisconnectFlag:usersWithOpenFiles = yes

afp:idleDisconnectFlag:guestUsers = yes

afp:recon1TokenTTLMins = 10080

afp:guestAccess = no

afp:allowRootLogin = no

afp:activityLogSize = 1000

afp:afpServerEncoding = 0

afp:createHomeDir = yes