Purchasing a Used Macbook Pro?

Good Evening Apple Community!


I hope everyone had a wonderful Christmas and is preparing to break in the New Year with a splash!


Recently, I have purchased a 13" Macbook Pro for my beloved wife. She uses it daily for work, communication and a bit of gaming every so often. Myself being a Hard-Core Die-Hard PC user, I wasn't sure how much I would enjoy using the Macbook... Boy was I in for a surprise.


Recently I have taken to using my wife's Macbook for video editing/audio recording and have fallen in love with OS X. The beauty of being able to boot up into a system that just 'works' and move right into a project is a breath of fresh air. Don't get me wrong, I love Microsoft and will never give up my Gaming Rig, but I find the overall makeup of the OS X an exhilarating experience and one I would like to continue to experience on a day-to-day basis.


That being said, here comes my question/dilemma: The price of a new Macbook Pro is quite out of my range (especially since my recent purchase for my wife). So I was browsing my local Craigslist and found 2 Macbooks that caught my eye. What I'm looking for is some advice on whether or not the listed price for these units is fair or atrocious. I'll list the specs below and the price and based on the knowledge of this community (which I know is vast), I feel I'll be able to gauge whether one of these notebooks would be a real bang for my buck.


1. MacBook "Core 2 Duo" 2.26 13" (Uni/Late 09)
2.26 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo processor
8 GB of DDR3 RAM
250 GB hard drive
Superdrive (plays & burns CDs/DVDs)
USB/ Ethernet/ Airport Wifi/ Bluetooth/ MiniDisplayport out/Headphone out
Built-in iSight webcam
13.3" widescreen display
AC adapter and a good battery (3 hours or so per charge)
Mac OS X 10.10.5 Yosemite installed
Various applications installed

(No Hardware Warranty - As-is)

Pictures:

(Top Cover

Bottom Cover

Left Side View

Right Side View

Open Laptop View

Crack On Left Side)

2. MacBook Pro

Display: 17"
Processors: 2.5GHz Core 2 Duo (T9300) (late 2008)
Memory: 4GB PC2-5300 SODIMM
Wireless: 802.11a/b/g/n
Color(s): Aluminum
OS: Mac OS X 10.10.5
Battery: 68-watt-hour removable lithium-polymer
Resolution: 1680x1050, 1920x1200
Finish: Glossy, Matte
Graphics: NVIDIA GeForce 8600M GT (512MB)
(Comes with a 90 hardware warranty)

Pictures:

(Top Cover

Left Side View

Right Side View

Open Laptop View)


Both of the Macbooks listed above are being advertised for $375 locally. As you can see from the photos shared above, the 15" Macbook Unibody has a lot of physical damage to the outer-shell of the unit, while the 17" Macbook Pro has, from all matters of appearances, an excellent well maintained body & screen.


Apple Community, what I'm asking is for your genuine opinion as to whether the price tag for either of these units is acceptable, and if so which one would be the better buy.


I'm really leaning towards the 17" Macbook Pro given the specs and overall look of the product. That in addition to the 90 Day Hardware Warranty (& the fact that I'm a sucker for a 17" screen) really pushes me towards wanting it that much more. The question is thought: Is the price their asking for fair or too much?


I'm going to be heading into the shop this week to check out the product personally with my wife, but would love some tips & advice before that time if anyone has any wisdom to share - from the price being fair/unfair to their personal experience with either MacBook.


Whatever the case, I thank you for taking the time to read this Forum Post and hope you have yourself a wonderful New Year!



Sincerely,

Adam P.

MacBook Pro, OS X Yosemite (10.10.5)

Posted on Dec 29, 2015 8:49 PM

Reply
6 replies

Dec 29, 2015 9:40 PM in response to steve359

Thanks for the quick response, Steve. Fortunately I have checked out Apple's Refurbished store & while I admit I'd love to have the added benefit of buying from Apple directly (since I know they'll back their products up both new and refurbished), the prices are still too much for me at this time. Hence why I was looking at a device retailer in my area who I might be able to snag a MacBook Pro off of for a couple hundred instead of a thousand.


Edit: The cheapest MacBook Pro currently available on Apple's Refurbished page is $1099.00.

Dec 29, 2015 10:03 PM in response to BiblicallySoundScripture

I <EDIT> CANNOT recommend either both <EDIT>, but others may say it is OK. First major reason is "CraigsList" ... I do not like that source.


These are the reasons Macs are worth the expense, in my opinion, and you get what you pay for:


> Apple selects quality parts to put on the logic board, and controls the manufacturing process

> Apple provides single-block-milled-out cases instead of pieced-together plastic things

> Apple provides free evaluations to fix their products

> Apple provides AppleCare to extend warranties to 3 years where HP/Dell get very fuzzy about that

> Apple makes operating systems that are very stable with device drivers suited to the parts in the systems


When you buy a $400 6-year-old Mac, you need to know how to do more than just "turn it on". You are past Apple working on the 2008 and probably past Apple working on the 2009. Some senior members in this forum (not "better than you", just "more experience than you") take on that challenge, but you will be up against a learning curve.

Dec 29, 2015 10:42 PM in response to steve359

Unfortunately a MacMini would not accommodate my active lifestyle and on-the-go demeanor. As of right now, I currently own a ASUS ROG G751JT 17" Notebook. It weighs over 9 pounds and thus has become my desktop replacement given what a powerhouse it is. While I can make it mobile (and do for LAN gaming parties), it remains on my desk otherwise as a semi-permanent desktop replacement.


That being said, the main reason I am looking for a (older) MacBook Pro is so I can have a Notebook on the go which can not only accomplish mundane tasks like surfing the web, receiving emails, etc. But also doubles as a mobile powerhouse/work station and enables me to edit videos, upload photos and overall just enjoy mobile life on the go.


The main reason I was looking for an older (perhaps even used) MBP is due to it's ability to be a powerhouse and mobile all at the same time. Being used, it would already have signs of light/heavy wear and thus I wouldn't be as concerned with outward appearance as much as inward durability.


If you have any suggestions on what model/year MBP I should look into, and possibly even a third-party source where you can get a killer deal, I'd be most appreciative.


I'm aware that taking on an older MBP will require a learning curve, but that's one thing that I don't mind doing. I'm passionate about my electronics and ever since I obtained my first iPhone 4S from my fiance (now wife), I have been hooked on Apple and willing/wanting to learn all I can about their products.


Thanks again for all the information you've given me thus far, I greatly appreciate it!

Dec 30, 2015 12:11 AM in response to BiblicallySoundScripture

The up-front possible issue(s) with Mac computers that were upgraded to a later OS X

than they shipped with, by someone who may have used their own AppleID, is first...


Problem with an OS X tied to someone elses AppleID account and upgraded past the

OS X the unit shipped with, is the ownership and further update/upgrade plus the use

of the App Store (and your ability to buy items from Apple, iTunes, etc) is closed to you.


Models that shipped with an OS X on DVD media for install-restore purposes, would be

expected to have those original system media discs included with the computer and be

running that system. You cannot actually upgrade (install) a new OS X from the internet

and not do so without a valid AppleID. The resulting OS X is tied to the individuals ID.


Both computers listed appear to be in the range of models which should have had their

system on DVD media, including original applications and an Apple Hardware Test.


• The MacBook Pro 17-inch Late 2008 model shipped with Leopard 10.5.x on discs made

for that build series model; that is what it should have with it and be running.


Original OS Mac OS X 10.5.4 (9E27)

Maximum OS Latest release of OS X

Hardware Test AHT 3A135

Bundled Software iLife ’08 (includes iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie, iDVD, iWeb, GarageBand)


Introduced October 2008

Discontinued January 2009

Model Identifier MacBookPro4,1

Model Number A1261

Order Number MB766LL/A


If it included the retail Snow Leopard 10.6.3 DVD install disc, then you could boot to that

and update to 10.6.8 from software update, and then consider the App Store to get newer

OS X system. Because your Apple ID is not attached to the Yosemite 10.10 OS X, it is

not available to you, even if you buy the computer that has been upgraded to that version.

(El Capitan, is most recent OS X from App Store; older Mountain Lion is a special purchase

from the Apple Store online, they will send you a code to download 10.8 from the App Store.)


The MacBook (13-inch Late 2009) model is slightly newer and shipped with OS X 10.6.x

DVD system discs made for that build model (like above, grey label install-restore media)

so that is what it should be running, plus the 10.6.8 update download, so you could go to

the App Store to consider an OS X later than the as-shipped included system.


Original OS Mac OS X 10.6.1 (10A2047)

Maximum OS Latest release of OS X

AirDrop Supported

Hardware Test AHT 3A181

Bundled Software iLife ’09 (includes iPhoto, iMovie, GarageBand, iWeb, iDVD)


Introduced October 2009

Discontinued May 2010

Model Identifier MacBook6,1

Model Number A1342

EMC 2350

Order Number MC207LL/A


Further information may be obtained by looking into the free database download app

from http://mactracker.ca and comparing information, as well as everymac.com site.


While the 17-inch MacBook Pro has a good deal of appeal, a 15 inch MacBook Pro

may be OK too, depending on if you happened to get a version that had few incidents

of graphic processor issues; as some sported dual graphic processors.


You may be able to find other sources of repaired MacBook or MacBook Pro models

online or in an Authorized Apple Service Provider nearer your location; online such

companies are in various locations across the US, and if elsewhere, almost every

country has a few. Or a technical expert who is capable to restore their function.


Some of those I've looked into their web site, are powerbookmedic, wegenermedia,

macsales, and other Apple authorized resellers who also offer service repairs, as

they have trained personnel and have access to replacement &/or upgrade parts.


{Both of the above computers could be set up for a new owner if they include OS X
Snow Leopard 10.6.3 retail DVD, then the new owner could see if they could erase

and install at least the level OS X required to use the Mac App Store online... After

those with 10.6.3 go to the Apple update server to get 10.6.8 update download.}


In any event...

Good luck & happy computing! 🙂

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Purchasing a Used Macbook Pro?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.