You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!
When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.
When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.
Hi There,
I am having a bit of trouble with the shared albums on iCloud.
When I upload photos to the shared album it seems to randomly put the photos in whatever order it likes rather than the order that I have selected.
Is there any reason for this or is there a way to manually sort the photos?
MacBook Air (13-inch, Early 2014), OS X El Capitan (10.11.2)
The terrible thing is the misleading name "Shared Album". We expect to be able to sort an album and to create a gallery of photos. But the so called "Shared Albums" are the old "Shared Photo Streams". Apple changed the name, but not the functionality. As a shared photo stream the share albums are working as expected. You drop a photo every now and then into a shared album and it is transmitted to all subscribers, a nice stream of photos in chronological order.
With the new name "Shared albums" we naturally expect to be able to arrange the photos in any order we think suitable. Apple should really either change the misleading name back to "Shared Photo Stream" or turn the streams into true albums.
The terrible thing is the misleading name "Shared Album". We expect to be able to sort an album and to create a gallery of photos. But the so called "Shared Albums" are the old "Shared Photo Streams". Apple changed the name, but not the functionality. As a shared photo stream the share albums are working as expected. You drop a photo every now and then into a shared album and it is transmitted to all subscribers, a nice stream of photos in chronological order.
With the new name "Shared albums" we naturally expect to be able to arrange the photos in any order we think suitable. Apple should really either change the misleading name back to "Shared Photo Stream" or turn the streams into true albums.
Apple, this is terrible. I have a gallery of 500 images I want to share with my family in the order in which they were taken, not in some random order that they upload. I'm not going to add them one by one. We know this can be done, but why you'd only permit sorting by date added baffles me. Love you, Apple, but sometimes you completely miss the mark. Truly disappointed. I now have to go figure a workaround.
Apple doesn’t routinely monitor the discussions. These are mostly user to user discussions.
Send Apple feedback. They won't answer, but at least will know there is a problem. If enough people send feedback, it may get the problem solved sooner.
Photos are sorted by the order they are added to the shared album. If you add a bunch at a time though they may not go into the order you think they should. Do them one by one to achieve the order you want.
I had this problem, too. But I think (fingers crossed) that I have 'solved' it.
When I first tried to create a shared album, I selected all the photos I wanted to share (in Photos on my Mac), did a right mouse click and selected iCloud sharing, or whatever. It uploaded them all and on my Mac the shared album showed them in the right order. But on my Apple TV they were in a random order. So I deleted the shared album and created another one. This time, within the new shared album, I clicked on 'Add photos and videos', selected the photos (or even 'moments' with multiple photos), clicked the 'Add' button and hey presto! The photos appeared on my Apple TVin the right order!
Hope this helps!
Workaround I just used:
1) View album in Photos on mac, select All (cmd+a), File > New Album, click OK to new 'untitled album'.
2) Check new untitled album, should have all the photos in date order.
3) Delete all images from shared album.
4) Select all images in untitled album, drag to shared album.
5) Check shared album, everything should be in date order.
6) Delete untitled album.
Ive tried this, but after some time all of the photos were rearranged
I'm not able to reproduce that.
iCloud Photo Shared Album sorting order
