PCM vs AAC - when does it really matter?

Hello


I am two-thirds of the way through a project to export 50 uncompressed talking head interviews. Each interview is approximately 3 hours long, so I am able to export about 2-3 projects per day. These are going to serve as the uncompressed masters that are preserved for the long haul. The audio is very simple, and not fantastic to begin with -- recorded with lavalier mics hooked up to a Canon HD camera.


Unfortunately, today I discovered a mistake in the export settings: my audio for the Quick Time Conversion has been set to AAC, and not PCM. For the most part, the material will be viewed online, but a small amount of it might eventually be broadcast.


After doing a few test exports, it seems that the PCM setting produces a file that is about 10-12% larger than the one with an AAC setting. To the "naked ear," there's no perceptible difference that I can tell. Should I be able to tell the difference, or would something like this be apparent only if heard through a professional sound system? If the latter, then re-exporting will be necessary without question.


If I re-export everything, this will set the project back by 2 weeks. Plus it will mean couriering the four 2TB external hard-drives (which are full of the completed exports) back from the preservationist who is across the country. It will be a major blow to the project timeline, but if it has to be done, then it has to be done.


Should I explain the situation and re-export, or will the increased quality in sound be so imperceptible that it wouldn't be worth it?


I'm a detail-oriented person, and this is making me sick with worry.


Thanks

Posted on Jan 21, 2016 11:53 PM

Reply
1 reply

Jun 20, 2017 10:53 PM in response to Anna Chronic

The answer to your question is not a function of the quality of the output of aac or whether one could hear the difference on an Internet stream or broadcast for that matter. Your deliverable was LPCM and you have not completed the project until you deliver what was specified.


If you deliver something less or different you will make the person who uses the archived material in the future "sick with worry".

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

PCM vs AAC - when does it really matter?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.