I too have issues with 4th Gen AppleTV on Wifi network that started sometime in January. Prior to that it all appeared to be working fine, and with no changes to the network, and everything else working fine, so strongly suspect a software update sometime in January on the 4th Gen AppleTV triggered the issue. Do you by chance over other Apple TVs on your network????
The symptoms of my issue is that the 4th Gen AppleTV was not able to maintain a connection on the Wifi network. It would connect, but soon drop out. I am using Cisco WLC 2504 controller and Cisco 3702 access points. The controller reported :-
Client Excluded: MACAddress:c8:69:cd:3e:1c:c2 Base Radio MAC :08:17:35:9d:b7:70 Slot: 1 User Name: unknown Ip Address: 192.168.10.72 Reason:Attempted to use IP Address assigned to another device. ReasonCode: 3
c8:69:cd:3e:1c:c2 is the MAC address of my 4th Gen Apple TV, HOWEVER, it is getting an IP address of 192.168.10.133 from DHCP (as seen
Normally this would suggest IP address conflicts, however, in this case there is no conflict. I have done a packet capture and the issue seems to be that the Gen 4 AppleTV is sending out gratuitous arp's from the IP address of another Gen 3 apple TV I have. Because of this the Cisco WLC thinks there is an address conflict and excludes the client. I have no idea why the Gen 4 AppleTV is sending gratuitous arp for another IP address. Not sure if this is a bug, or some mechanism Apple is trying to spoof the other apple TV's???? But whatever it is, is causing the issue an needs to be fixed.
For reference, I have 3 Gen 3 Apple TVs as well as the Gen 4 apple TV on the network. If I turn the Gen3 AppleTV off that is using the IP address listed (192.168.10.72), the Gen 4 Apple TV seems to work better for a small period of time, however, before too long the problem happens again, but this time with 1 of the other Gen 3 apple TVs that are still on.
Does anyone have a fix for this issue. Can a bug be raised with apple to fix the issue?