When I pause a song, it starts over the next time I play.

Is there a setting I am missing somewhere? I cannot find a setting related to automatically starting songs over, or allowing paused songs to stay paused.

It behaves like a bug, but it's 2016 so sadly I expect Apple thinks it a feature (part of their mission to antagonize music fans which began with iTunes 9). The important part is I cannot find a setting to "Prevent songs from starting over on their own"