Shutdown instead of Standby Problem

Greetings and felicitations,


On my MacBook Pro 3,1, when the battery power drops below 10% I get a low power warning. If I keep the computer on much after this it goes into standby mode (preserving exactly how everything was), and can be ‘woken’ once it’s connected to a power supply. Perfect!


My wife’s slightly newer MacBook5,1 doesn’t do this. There is no warning (that I’ve noticed) and eventually, the computer just shuts down unceremoniously.

How can I change this? I don’t see anything in the system preferences that might control this. Am I missing something? Is there a fix? It's done this ever since she bought it (new).


Any help is appreciated!

Posted on Mar 30, 2016 1:34 PM

Reply
4 replies

Apr 6, 2016 9:07 PM in response to SeaPapp

Hi Mike, thanks for the quick reply.


I had her computer completely disassembled, cleaned and upgraded by a tech before I posted (and yes, this was a problem before as well). cmd-opt-P-R is the first thing I'd tried before the tech got it. I just tried resetting the SMC, and that didn't have any effect.


My other Mac laptop (older than hers) does a save-state and hibernates until it's connected to a power supply. So I assume that's the norm.


When I upgraded hers to 10.11.3 it, at least, started warning me before shutting down (it still just dies, but at least now I have some warning).


Any other suggestions?

Thanks again,

Micah

Apr 7, 2016 1:42 AM in response to Micah Wolfe

When you had the computer taken apart and cleaned, what was the status of the battery?


If the battery has seen too many (one or more) 'run-flat scenarios' where the battery is ran

until the computer can barely be shut down, or reverts to sleep by itself; the end is nearer

than if you were to leave 30% life in the battery and just top it off, instead of running it flat.



• About Mac notebook batteries - Apple Support

• Apple Portables: Troubleshooting MagSafe adapters - Apple Support


Depending on how the computer is handled, the settings and user habits, and how often

the battery is cycled (charge-discharge-recharge) will directly cause shortness of its life.


A lower-power setting for the display, is one of the easiest things to save battery life; in

more than just one sitting, every thing you can do to conserve, helps. And some items

will also keep the computer running cooler, with several components lasting longer.


Some processor-intensive applications, or streaming video/music by wireless, can use a

fair amount of energy resources since some of them also invite temporary swap file use

that cycle data files to and from the storage drive. Less energy in that, with an SSD; still

a fair amount of energy if using the battery as primary source of power for those tasks.


The Console utility system logs may hold some clues about the battery and power status;

or what has been happening (cryptic language) that may be difficult to understand. The

Activity Monitor is an OK thing to look into at times; earlier versions seemed easier to see

what was happening. OS X has changed a bit; system resources still demand quite a lot.


There probably are some low-footprint apps that can show how the power reserves are

used; like those widget or graphic representations. In older OS X I'd preferred iStat Pro

since it had several handy references; the last versions weren't the same.


Conflicting software or mis-matched bits from older systems no longer supported may be

slowing down the computer, and items such as scanning antivirus or other poor utilities

can be using resources to help drain the battery unnecessarily & without an advantage.


Be sure to maintain additional backups of your computer contents to archives sustained

off-computer; and in addition to TimeMachine in external storage drive. To learn how &

use clones as an additional backup (alongside other methods) is a good idea. To reduce

odds of losing your content should the computer completely fail, and allow data recovery.


Good luck & happy computing! 🙂

Apr 17, 2016 2:27 PM in response to K Shaffer

Hi K!


The battery is brand new, which hasn't changed the behavior.


On the plus side, after all of the work that's gone into it, the computer now tells you roughly 30 seconds before it shuts off. It still doesn’t do a saved state, or shutdown programs. It just turns off. It will reopen the programs which were open when it shut off, but no info is saved (specific documents may not open, but the application will, regardless.


I don’t generally run batteries to zero, and only am doing it now for testing, and like I said…new battery.

This computer has a new hard drive, new OS install, no data transferred. It has new RAM (Corsair, I think), and is pretty much a new system in terms of what can be easily replaced.


Same problem persists.

Thank you for all the general tips. They’re always appreciated as well.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Shutdown instead of Standby Problem

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.