SSD Not Recognized, Internally or Via USB

Very long story, there are similar posts on here but other situations aren't the same as mine and/or the replies don't explain things very well. I'm trying to replace the hard drive in my mid-2010 MBP with a modern SSD, the manufacturer tells me it is not formatted (people are saying you need to format it first, in response saying that their OS does not recognize it in any way, shape or form, as is my situation). When I put it in the internal drive bay I get the big "?", sometimes alternates between that and the apple icon and the circle with a slash through it (which to mean indicates that there is unrecognized hardware connected). I bought the cable I need to connect it via USB, I have the original hard drive cloned to another external drive that I intend to use to keep my MBP backed up, I want to clone the original hard drive to the new SSD, then try booting from it. I'm pretty sure I have to format the SSD but how can I do that if it is not recognized? When I connect it externally to a Windows (7) machine it is recognized in Device Manager (but not in My Computer).


Thanks

MacBook Pro, OS X El Capitan (10.11.3)

Posted on Apr 2, 2016 11:08 AM

Reply
14 replies

Apr 2, 2016 4:28 PM in response to gearjamminsob

I suggest that you install your SSD in an enclosure OWC external case or using a USB to SATA adapter USB to SATA adapter and connect it to your MBP via USB.


Open Disk Utility>Erase and format the SSD to Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and a GUID partition.


Then use a third party application such as Carbon Copy Cloner Carbon Copy Cloner (Not free, but worth the price) or Super Duper to copy all data from the internal HDD as well as the recovery partition.


The clone will be a exact copy of your hard drive and it will be bootable.


Boot the MBP with the OPTION key (Startup Manager) and select the new SSD. How to choose a startup disk on your Mac


If it boots the MBP, perform the physical swap of drives.


Hope this helps,

Kim

Apr 2, 2016 11:29 AM in response to Csound1

I have no reason to think it does not work, I typed that it is not recognized and asked how to format a disk when it is not recognized, your response was to format for Mac, this is exactly what I mean by replies that do not explain anything, I kinda had that part figured out, that any drive used under a Mac OsX would have to be formatted with a Mac format. There appears to be nothing wrong with the drive, Windows has no problem formatting it under NTFS, after that is done I will try what KimUserName suggested (and see if it is even recognized by Disk Utility after Windows puts some sort of formatting on it). Perhaps you could read the entire qeustion before replying next time, Csound1

Apr 2, 2016 12:00 PM in response to Csound1

Csound1, thanks for taking a shot at helping with my situation, sorry to sound like I was dumping all over your reply but it really was the unuseful sort of reply I mentioned in my original post, I asked how to format a drive that El Capitan failed to recognize and you replied to format if for Mac. It is not faulty, when you told me to "buy a drive that works next time" I did not know that to be the problem and suspected otherwise so I was looking for information on what to do with a working drive that my OsX won't play with. There are a lot of cogs in this chain and I figured the problem was with one of the other ones (and it was - I'm getting somewhere).

Apr 2, 2016 12:04 PM in response to KimUserName

Alright, I will watch that video, but I am getting somewhere. You mentioned that I should use and enclosure, I don't have one, I have a powred cable with the SATA interface and a USB cable. However, I tried taking out the original hard drive and replacing it with the (NTFS-formatted) SSD, after setting my MBP to boot form the other external drive, which contains a clone of the original hard drive. This has worked, in so far as I am in El Capitan, and now Disk Utility does recognize the SSD. I'm guessing I have to erase, then probably after doing so I will be able to reformat (of course, I'd select Mac Extended ((Journaled))).

Apr 2, 2016 12:08 PM in response to OGELTHORPE

Yes, I have heard of this being a solution in some cases, that will be my next step but up until now it was not recognized at all, by my MBP, so I've been trying to figure why that is so I can test whether the rest of the BUS will play with this SSD. It is recognized internally now, so once I get it formatted for Mac I will have a better idea if I can use it with the rest of the architecture I have or if I need to buy a new SATA cable.


Thanks

Apr 2, 2016 12:42 PM in response to gearjamminsob

gearjamminsob wrote:


Csound1, thanks for taking a shot at helping with my situation, sorry to sound like I was dumping all over your reply but it really was the unuseful sort of reply I mentioned in my original post, I asked how to format a drive that El Capitan failed to recognize and you replied to format if for Mac. It is not faulty, when you told me to "buy a drive that works next time" I did not know that to be the problem and suspected otherwise so I was looking for information on what to do with a working drive that my OsX won't play with. There are a lot of cogs in this chain and I figured the problem was with one of the other ones (and it was - I'm getting somewhere).

If the drive does not register at all it is defective.


Maybe it is recognized (in disk utility) perhaps, but I don't know and you want tell me, so good luck

Apr 2, 2016 4:40 PM in response to gearjamminsob

Thanks to all who replied, for the record, and for the benefit of those who have a similar problem (seems there are more than a few) the drive was fine and it is up an running as an internal drive on my MBP. What I ended up having to do is format it in a Windows machine first, after which it still was not recognized as an external drive my my Mac. However, once formatted in NTFS, when I booted from another external drive (with the machine's original hard drive cloned to it) my MBP recognized it internally, using the original SATA cable. With this drive, and I also doubled RAM to 8GB, my computer runs quite a lot faster.

Apr 2, 2016 4:59 PM in response to gearjamminsob

Glad to hear your problems are all ironed out.


Here is another video you may find interesting about drive SATA cables.


MacBook Pro hard drive SATA cable issue. MacBook Pro Hard Drive Cable Failure-Free fix and preventative maintenance

Quite often when changing from HDD to SSD, people have found issues with the drive SATA cable. I guess SSD's are much more sensitive to a failing SATA cable.

Just something to keep in mind for the future.

Kim

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

SSD Not Recognized, Internally or Via USB

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.