What makes Macbooks better than Dell laptops?

Hello everyone. Mac newbie here.


My name is Ken. I'm a 25-year-old grad student studying chemical engineering, at the same time working part-time as a laboratory technologist.


I've been using PC laptops ever since high school. However, most of the PC's I owned in the past would end up becoming deficient in overall performance. Now, two years ago, I purchased a Dell XPS 13 from a Microsoft store. At first, I was fine with it. But, within the past couple of months, my Dell XPS started acting up and demonstrating inadequate performance. For some reason, it has these little quirks, such as randomly locking up on me.


Therefore, I've made the decision to dump Dell and purchase my first Macbook.


According to detailed specifications, the Dell XPS 13 is lighter and slimmer than Macbooks are. More significantly, the Dell XPS 13 has a better processor, and has a higher-resolution display than Macbooks do.


Yet, I've become frustrated with PC's over the years, and I'm now turning to Macs.


So I need your opinions, guys.


In terms of performance and reliability-


What makes Macbooks better than Dell laptops?


What advantages do Macbooks have over Dell, given the XPS 13's aforementioned specs?


I look forward to hearing what you have to say.


Thank you guys.

MacBook Pro with Retina display, OS X Mavericks (10.9)

Posted on Apr 19, 2016 8:29 PM

Reply
20 replies

Apr 19, 2016 9:26 PM in response to steve359

I would be slightly careful about Dell having more processing power

It depends on what you intend on using the MB for but the Pro models go up to 16GB and 2.8 Ghz - that is plenty of power even for someone that deals in graphics and videos

Now if you are gamer - the field is slightly more evenly split but pound for pound the Mac leaves the PC in the dust - the performance is flawless and as you may glean from some of the posts here people have updated macs from 2009 and 2010 with the latest OS

The advantages of Apple are legion - suffice to say with the latest Macs - get as much RAM as you can afford - ditto for SSD since those are not user replaceable

Apr 19, 2016 8:43 PM in response to Jericho-79

My story, in short ...


I wanted a notebook (MBPs are notebooks not laptops). I despised Windows OS for it sgross instability (the most likely cause of many of your slowdowns). I wanted a UNIX-based notebook.


I was at first a bit hesitant to jump into Apple's self-controlled world of OSX, but bit the bullet and am so glad I did. My MBP is not several plastic sheets, but a single block of aluminum milled to hold the parts. The OSX rarely fully locks ... at worst I usually "ForceQuit" the offending application and maybe wait a minute for the cleanup ... and even then mostly for third-party non-OSX applications like FireFox.


Some have dropped their MBPs, bruised the corner visibbly, but the system runs on. My 2011 MBP runs strong even now. OSX can run for months between shutdown without the "panics" typical of Windows.


My MB cam from this site ... Apple-refurbished units. Apple fully verifies all parts during refurbish process so they can run for years as indistinguishable from new: http://www.apple.com/shop/browse/home/specialdeals/mac

Apr 21, 2016 2:15 PM in response to Jericho-79

Hey Steve and ManSinha. Thanks for your input.


So basically, the Mac OS performance is just superior to the Windows OS performance. The Mac OS hardly demonstrates any glitches or quirks.


I'm only going to use my Macbook for word processing, web surfing, Youtubing, and picture posting. I won't be doing any gaming, video editing, Photoshopping, or Netflixing. I'm still considering the MBP for its processing power.



Speaking of that- What do you guys think of the Dell XPS having a higher resolution than the MBP Retina does? (MBP's 2560x1600 vs. Dell XPS's 3200 x 1800).

Apr 21, 2016 2:26 PM in response to Jericho-79

Some PCs run faster ... for a while. Windows 10 is better than previous versions, but still not quite as good at isolating applications into their memory space as OSX. OSX does a good job of allowing the forced kill of problem programs with just a short delay while the scattered remains are cleaned up. Windows can lose its entire network table due just to a remote system doing a force-kill of your session.


Also ... Apple stores will at least look at a Mac for 5-6 years for free if you have a question. You may not like the estimate for repair, but they will. (After 5-6 years it is "obsolete" so goes off support). That does not mean the system is useless after 5-6 years, just that Genius Bar cannot help.


Also some still run their 2008 MBPs as webbrowser systems.


As to resolution ... more pixels in the end is for games or photos than general applications. In the end, the top menu bar has to be physically large enough for you to see it, whether it uses 10 pixels tall or 40 pixels tall.

Apr 21, 2016 2:55 PM in response to Jericho-79

I used to work in a steel industry and I was in charge of Automation support for PLC's, HMI, ThinClients, etc.

I found a lot of the time what you are doing on a Windows machine is trying to figure out why something isn't working.

Also constantly updating Virus Scanners. Once you got done installing all the updates, you then found something would not work.


Since retiring and switching to Mac I find I am doing very little time on computer maintenance.

Macs do not get viruses and it is recommended not to run a Virus Checker.

No need to defray files, Macs look after all that stuff on there own.


Also do you think you can find a 2009 windows pc capable of running Windows 10?

You will find a lot of people on this forum running computer as old or older than 2009 and running El Capitan with no problems.

I have a 13" early 2011 MacBook Pro and I am running El Capitan. I have a 500 GB flash drive and 8GB of RAM and computer speeds are very good.


As mentions in earlier posts, determine what size hard drive and how much RAM you require because they are not upgradeable.

I have read numerous post from people wondering how to upgrade their SSD because they bought one which was too small.


I think you will be quite happy buying a Mac.


Kim

Apr 21, 2016 3:30 PM in response to Jericho-79

And just to add one more viewpoint: Where I work Macs and Dells are the two most popular computer brands. I seldom see Dell notebooks older than 3 years and when I do I also see duct tape, mice, and people in search of wall outlets because their computers are getting 60 minutes or less on a charge. At three years a Mac notebook is still going strong and poor battery life is still measured in hours rather than minutes.

Apr 25, 2016 9:31 AM in response to KimUserName

OP here, guys. This has been getting under my skin for a while.


At every workplace that I've worked in, I would always see Dell, HP, Acer, and Lenovo desktops at employees' workstations. On the other hand, when I stroll through the public parks in NYC, everyday people are with their Macbooks.


Why are workplaces using PCs all the time? Will workplaces ever switch to Macs?

Apr 25, 2016 10:05 AM in response to Jericho-79

I used to work at a Steel Company in Canada.

Most of the software we used worked with Windows only. Very little would work with Mac.

Also all the desktop computers in the company were supplied by our IT department.

When I left, just a little over a year ago, most of our desktop computers were being replaced by ThinClients connected over a network.

Only select personel could get full computers, and you had to justify them. The computers we got were based on who would give the company the best deal. Usually it was either Dell or HP as you have indicated.

As far as laptops, when the IT department looked into replacing our laptops every 3-5 years they would normally look at the personnel who worked in our main office to see what specs were needed.

So when it came time to turn in your laptop for a new one you would find that the much needed ports that you needed like serial ports, etc. would not longer be supplied. You would now have USB ports instead. At this point you would have to try and figure out a way to connect your new laptop to a PLC or some other piece of equipment, which you previously connected via serial port.


Anyway, you get the picture.


Kim

Apr 25, 2016 10:39 AM in response to Jericho-79

Windows PC are not the mainstay that they once were but in many cases they remain the default machine largely due to low price per unit. When the IT department can replace a PC notebook or desktop for 1/3 to 1/2 the price of a Mac it looks like they are spending wisely. That Macs last longer and require less support is irrelevant to this way of thinking.


In my wife’s office Windows was a requirement until recently because their national reporting software required Internet Explorer. Last year new platform agnostic software was rolled out and techs are now using iPads while office work is being done on Macs. One lone PC remains because I decided it was easier and cheaper to keep their document and email server and database backend on it than to move it all but I’ll rethink that decision in a couple years.

Apr 26, 2016 12:49 PM in response to dwb

Thanks for everything, guys. I have one last question before I buy my first Macbook.


I've finally decided to purchase a Macbook Air, due to its long battery life.


Now here's my question-


Should I opt to get the 3-year AppleCare Protection Plan?


I don't wish to shell out an additional $200 for an insurance plan that I won't end up needing. Especially when the majority of Mac users out there never seem to have any problems with their notebooks.

Apr 26, 2016 1:03 PM in response to Jericho-79

Should I opt to get the 3-year AppleCare Protection Plan?


In my opinion, you should ALWAYS opt for the extended protection plan for any portable computer. It operates on a battery, can be placed in a backpack and carted around, and is subject to tremendous G-forces when you transport it.


Insurance is there to cover eventualities that you cannot afford to absorb on your own. But Insurance by nature spreads that risk over a pool of people -- some will need it, some will not.


If you can not afford to replace an US$800 motherboard on your own, buy the Insurance. If you don't turn out to actually collect on it, that will be good.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

What makes Macbooks better than Dell laptops?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.