Q: Migrate directly or from backup?

When a Mac dies -- if the hard drive is OK -- should you migrate directly or from a backup?

Does the new Mac check the old one's file system journal to make sure everything is OK and put the data back in a known-good state?

I'm thinking that if the Mac suddenly died, I don't know if that hardware issue might affect the data on the hard drive, so maybe that argues for going from a backup. But then there's always the possibility there could be an issue with the backup. (We have a backup that's at most an hour old.)

Thank you in advance!

iMac

Posted on Sep 7, 2016 6:51 AM

I have this question too

Q: Migrate directly or from backup?

All replies

Helpful answers

by Csound1,

Csound1 Sep 7, 2016 6:54 AM in response to DonnaR
Level 9 (50,103 points)

Desktops

Sep 7, 2016 6:54 AM in response to DonnaR

If possible I would migrate directly, the backup is a good option when you can't.
Reply options

Link to this post

by dialabrain,

dialabrain Sep 7, 2016 6:55 AM in response to DonnaR
Level 5 (5,820 points)

Mac App Store

Sep 7, 2016 6:55 AM in response to DonnaR

If you mean onto a new Mac, you would have to migrate from the backup if the Mac is dead.
Reply options

Link to this post

by DonnaR,

DonnaR Sep 7, 2016 7:02 AM in response to dialabrain
Level 1 (147 points)

Mac OS X

Sep 7, 2016 7:02 AM in response to dialabrain

True, if you were to do it yourself! But you can always bring it in to a computer repair place, and they could do the transfer.

In that case, which would you trust more: the original (but that might be compromised because of the hardware issue that caused it to die) or a backup?

Thanks again!
Reply options

Link to this post

by Csound1,Helpful

Csound1 Sep 7, 2016 7:47 AM in response to DonnaR
Level 9 (50,103 points)

Desktops

Sep 7, 2016 7:47 AM in response to DonnaR

I would use the original every time it is available.
Reply options

Link to this post

by dialabrain,Helpful

dialabrain Sep 7, 2016 7:39 AM in response to DonnaR
Level 5 (5,820 points)

Mac App Store

Sep 7, 2016 7:39 AM in response to DonnaR

FWIW, if the "computer repair place" is an Apple store or an AASP then I would feel more comfortable with a recommendation. If it's not, I wouldn't let them touch my Macs. I would just do it myself. And, since I'm not about to pull out the drive and buy a new enclosure, I would use the backup to recover what data I could and reinstall any apps I needed to.
Reply options

Link to this post

Q: Migrate directly or from backup?

All replies Helpful answers

by Csound1,

by dialabrain,

by DonnaR,

by Csound1,★Helpful

by dialabrain,★Helpful

All replies

Helpful answers

by Csound1,Helpful

by dialabrain,Helpful