Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Find referenced file

Hi all

I always used referenced files since i used Aperture. Now i use Photos since many month....

I noticed that i have some albums that files cannot be find on my external disk when i control-click on the picture and ask to display the referenced file.

This is why I 'm no be able to use theses albums with my AppleTV and cannot export pictures from theses albums.

I don't find the possibility to relocated referenced files as in Aperture which had a menu for that.

Thank you for your help.

Posted on Dec 28, 2016 5:31 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Dec 28, 2016 1:38 PM

The support for referenced files in Photos is limited.

You can import photos as referenced, but there is no way to relocate referenced files to a new location, and there is no panel to reconnect missing files like Aperture had.

The only supported action is "Consolidate" to copy the originals into the library.


If a referenced file cannot be found, you have to search for it on your own and point Photos to its location.

The question remains, why Photos cannot access your referenced files.

Is your external drive locally mounted and formatted MacOS Extended (Journaled)? On a NAS you may have problems with the referenced files on Sierra.


In Photos it is much safer to consolidate all referenced files into the library, and then use File > Export to create a folder with copies of the photos, if you need to access them outside Photos.

5 replies
Sort By: 
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Dec 28, 2016 1:38 PM in response to nelsonfr

The support for referenced files in Photos is limited.

You can import photos as referenced, but there is no way to relocate referenced files to a new location, and there is no panel to reconnect missing files like Aperture had.

The only supported action is "Consolidate" to copy the originals into the library.


If a referenced file cannot be found, you have to search for it on your own and point Photos to its location.

The question remains, why Photos cannot access your referenced files.

Is your external drive locally mounted and formatted MacOS Extended (Journaled)? On a NAS you may have problems with the referenced files on Sierra.


In Photos it is much safer to consolidate all referenced files into the library, and then use File > Export to create a folder with copies of the photos, if you need to access them outside Photos.

Reply

Dec 28, 2016 1:38 PM in response to nelsonfr

Unfortunately Photos does not handle referenced files well adn they are not recommended - there is no ability to relocate referenced files with Photos and many other reasons not to use them - Disadvantages of a Referenced Library in Photos


You need to rethink your use of referenced photos and strongly consider consolidating them into your library - it is the recommended way to use Photos


LN

Reply

Dec 28, 2016 1:43 PM in response to nelsonfr

Thank you for quick reply. It was a very good solution with Aperture ! I develop my Raw files with DxO and have output files in a folder with the jepg file. After i make an album in Photos and keep the same name than my folder with jpeg.

I don't work raw files in Photos. Photos is only for albums, and sharing (mail; Apple TV....)

When i need , or if i want to try an other software to develop raw files, it is better to have all pictures on an extern hard drive. Maybe i 'll try an other solution than Photos....

Best regards

Reply

Dec 31, 2016 1:04 AM in response to interstellarlord

That is exactly what I meant by "limited" support for referenced files. The pop-up window does not tell you anything about the missing file, and not where the file used to be, just the filename. Aperture has an elaborate reconnect window, where you can compare the file attributes of the missing file with any file you found. And you can automatically reconnect all files found in the similar location.

Reply

Find referenced file

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.