Did Photos duplicate my iPhoto library?

Old, long-time Apple user here (first with an Apple II in 1977-78), but slow to move to newer Macs. As an old guy (and cost-conscious), I just replaced my old 2007 iMac with a new one for Christmas. I'm running 10.12.2, and my old Mac I never went past the cats. Thus, all the "new to me" apps are taking a bit to get accustomed.


I think my question really starts with "if I am not using an iPhone and do not connect my photos online except by my own choice" is Photos what I should be using? When I got the computer a week or so ago, I saw that I could download a copy of iPhoto. Should I just keep using iPhoto?


But, trying to do new things, I did start up Photos just to see what it was like. It took about 2 hours to migrate my 256GB of pictures in my iPhoto library into Photos. Now, using Finder, I see that the Photos Library is also about 250 GB (not quite the same...curious that). So, did I just duplicate the entire photo library?


Can I assume correctly that after I choose one or the other (let's assume Photos), then I can just delete the other 250GB file? Or, more likely, migrate it off to one of my external hard drives?

macOS Sierra (10.12.2), iMac 2015

Posted on Jan 16, 2017 4:28 PM

Reply
7 replies

Sep 30, 2017 3:57 AM in response to intreno

According to that, if I now delete the iPhoto library, for sure I clean at least the space of all those images taken up to 2015 that I afterwords deleted from Photo (i.e. 10 GB). Am I mistaken?

Yes. If you delete the iPhoto Library, the storage will be freed for all photos and videos, that you already deleted from the Photos Library. For your newer photos and videos that still have the hard linked copies in Photos, the storage will not be freed, because the copies in Photos are still stored there.

Jan 16, 2017 4:56 PM in response to Carl Creasman1

You should be using Photos - it is better in pretty much every way than iPhoto and iPhoto is a dead product that will totally quit working some day - Photos is a new and different program and has a learning curve and requires different workflows


And to use iPHoto you would have to have version 9.6.1 which since you were not up to date probably is not possible to install


And no, nothing was duplicated - Photos and iPhoto use hard links to share access to the same originals and the same previews - Photos saves disk space by sharing images with your iPhoto or Aperture libraries - Apple Support


You can delete either library with no effect on the other but it is not recommended until you have used Photos for a while - three or more months


LN

Sep 30, 2017 12:09 AM in response to léonie

I still have not clear the issue in my mind. I understand that there is an hard link, but what happens when you delete an image on Photos Library? I try to specify it more. After migrating from iPhoto to Photo (i.e. in 2015), I continued uploading photos and videos on Photo. Then I also deleted many videos from Photo (let's say 10 GB). Now, if I access the iPhoto library (it took half a day, since it re-creates the environment), I find photos and videos up to 2015, also videos I deleted on Photo. So, iPhoto library seems more or less a static picture of the library taken on 2015. According to that, if I now delete the iPhoto library, for sure I clean at least the space of all those images taken up to 2015 that I afterwords deleted from Photo (i.e. 10 GB). Am I mistaken?

Jan 18, 2017 6:17 PM in response to Carl Creasman1

AS I said


And to use iPHoto you would have to have version 9.6.1 which since you were not up to date probably is not possible to install


And as to the finder size that is explained in the link I provided - did you read it?


When Finder reports the file size of your Photos library, it includes all your originals and previews. It may look like your remaining iPhoto or Aperture library is taking up twice the space on your hard drive, but it isn't—your images exist only in one location, even though you may have more than one photo library.



And yes you can delete the old iPhoto library but there is no reason to and it is not recommended until you have used Photos for a while


LN

Jan 18, 2017 6:18 PM in response to Carl Creasman1

.can you (or anyone) help me understand why Finder shows the roughly 250GB with both libraries?

Photos creates a new library. Both the old iPhoto Library and the new Photos library contain all photos and can be used independently. But the new image files in the Photos Library are hard links to the image files in the iPhoto Library. A hard link is a full file, the same size as the original, but it is using the same disk blocks as the original file. This way both libraries are having the same size in the Finder, but are sharing the storage efficiently.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Did Photos duplicate my iPhoto library?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.