Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Activity Monitor confusing

I have a CAD program that is hogging CPU time and causing long waits with spinning wheel, “not responding” messages, etc. It is actually grinding its way through the task, but I wanted to monitor if it was actually working and not hung up.


So, I open Activity Monitor, set to CPU, and put it on a side screen to watch.


The CAD program registered

"% CPU" at 100-100.1%,

“System" about 5%

“Idle" about 85%. The

"CPU Load" ribbon about 5-10% of the height of the window.


None of this makes any sense. % CPU, System, and CPU Load should be about the same.


Is there some hidden definition not represented by the labels? These should make more sense.

MacBook Pro with Retina display, macOS Sierra (10.12.3)

Posted on Mar 20, 2017 7:43 AM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Mar 20, 2017 8:40 AM

OK, all that makes sense. Why doesn’t the AM app present that clearly? It could easily indicate the cores and their loads. To me CPU means all the cores, so the reference would be to all the cores.


The Activity Monitor could be programmed a lot more clearly.


Thanks for the explanation.

7 replies
Question marked as Best reply

Mar 20, 2017 8:40 AM in response to dialabrain

OK, all that makes sense. Why doesn’t the AM app present that clearly? It could easily indicate the cores and their loads. To me CPU means all the cores, so the reference would be to all the cores.


The Activity Monitor could be programmed a lot more clearly.


Thanks for the explanation.

Mar 20, 2017 8:40 AM in response to Cosman

Cosman wrote:


I have a CAD program that is hogging CPU time and causing long waits with spinning wheel, “not responding” messages, etc. It is actually grinding its way through the task, but I wanted to monitor if it was actually working and not hung up.


So, I open Activity Monitor, set to CPU, and put it on a side screen to watch.


The CAD program registered

"% CPU" at 100-100.1%,

“System" about 5%

“Idle" about 85%. The

"CPU Load" ribbon about 5-10% of the height of the window.


None of this makes any sense. % CPU, System, and CPU Load should be about the same.


Is there some hidden definition not represented by the labels? These should make more sense.

Actually, it can make a lot of sense, but you need to be aware of a few things.

Your mac has several cores, physical or virtual. How a program uses those cores depends on how it is written. Many programs can use only one core, others can leverage several cores at once in parallel.

The 100% you see in %CPU means the program is fully utilizing ONE core.

The 85% refers to all the available cores. So for example if you have 8 logical cores (like most iMacs, or 15" MBP) one program utilizing one core at 100% plus other system processes and applications doing light work will translate to about 85% idle overall.

Mar 20, 2017 8:28 AM in response to John Galt

OK, let me sort this out. From Use Activity Monitor on your Mac:


...the “% CPU” column …(is)... the percentage of CPU capability used by each process

In this case ~ 100% for the CAD pgm.


2. System: The percentage of CPU capability currently used by system processes, which are processes that belong to macOS


This says my system (not CAD) is using ~ 2-5%, so the total of 1. & 2. is now ~ 105% CPU load

3. User: The percentage of CPU capability currently used by apps that you opened, or by the processes those apps opened.


This column has my name in it as the user. There is no CPU capability or % or anything else in that column. This is misstated. It should read “the User associated with the %CPU in col 1."

4. Idle: The percentage of CPU capability not being used.


How can the idle show 96% when 1. and 2. indicate 105% being used? Idle should be -5%.


5. CPU Load: The percentage of CPU capability currently used by all System and User processes.

Again, this graph should indicate 105% of the CPU capability in use. It shows maybe 5-10%.

Still doesn’t make sense.

Activity Monitor confusing

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.