Volume triggered Muffled Speakers - 2016 MBP 15” Fault (w/ Video Demonstration)

Hello all,

I’m having an unusual problem with my Late 2016 Macbook Pro 15” with Touchbar (model shipping 17th December 2016).

Whenever playing audio that reaches a certain volume the internal speakers would become muffled. When lowering the volume the sound continues to be muffled. The only way to get clear sound is to either:

  • Restart my Macbook
  • Plug in headphones and pull them out again
  • Type ‘midi’ into spotlight to enter ‘Audio MIDI Setup’ and change the audio frequency (Hz) of the Internal Speakers output.
  • Killing the ‘coreaudiod’ process within terminal or activity monitor and restarting it.

Increasing the volume again will result in the audio becoming muffled again.

In this video I demonstrate the problem in detail.

I find this problem unusual as I’ve searched extensively for a resolution and cannot find anyone else with the same problem. I realise there was a problem around launch with bootcamp audio drivers breaking the speakers. However I had never used bootcamp and this problem started in the past week.

Here are the things I’ve tried

  • I’ve reset the NVRAM/PRAM (on multiple occasions) [Via. boot keypresses & terminal]
  • I’ve reset SMC (on multiple occasions, however as there is no confirmation I’m unsure if it really processed)
  • I’ve formatted & reinstalled OSX Sierra (version 10.12.5)
  • I’ve formatted & Internet Recovered OSX Sierra (version 10.12.5)
  • I’ve downloaded an older version of OSX Sierra (version 10.12.2) and installed it.

Yet, the problem remains.

I decided to install Windows 10 via. Bootcamp and the problem no longer occurred. However after some use it started occurring. I believe it is harder to trigger the muffled sound as Windows 10’s maximum volume on the MBP 2016 is lower.

Apple Diagnostics report reference code ADP000 ‘No issues found’.

I’m tech savvy, however am stumped at what is causing this.

Hopefully some of you have some ideas?

At first I thought it was a software issue however after trying everything outlined above I no longer think this is the case. Do you think I should take my mac in for warranty? This is a last resort as I’d hate to be without my mac for a week.

See the full demonstration on YouTube here!

Keywords to help others search for this problem.

Poor Quality Sound, Low Quality Audio, Sounding Distant, Sounding Hollow, Sounding Underwater, Low Pitched, Distorted, Deep

MacBook Pro (15-inch, Late 2016), macOS Sierra (10.12.5)

Posted on Jul 16, 2017 5:09 AM

Reply
134 replies

Jun 10, 2019 7:52 AM in response to matt_90

I have this same problem on my late-2016 MBP 15" with touch bar.

Just happened 2 days ago and the best part is that my warranty is expired...

I can't believed this, first there was the keyboard issue then now this...

When they told me that Apple was expensive... I didn't listen.

This laptop is not even 3 years old, I expect more when buying an Apple product.

I should have bought the Apple Care plus, stupid me...

I will call Apple tomorrow to see if they can help in any way and will keep you guys posted.

Jul 9, 2019 6:21 AM in response to matt_90

Hi Matt,


Can you tell us whether 2 years on you have managed to fix the issue?


I have exactly the same issue as you (MacBook Pro 15-inch, 2017), but it appeared to start when plugging in the power cable into one of the USB-C ports on the left side. I heard a crackle noise and I always assumed it somehow fried the speaker as it only happens to the left speaker.


I have an appointment for this Friday at the Apple Store, but any update from you would be great.


Thanks!

Jul 28, 2019 2:50 PM in response to matt_90

Hello, was anyone able to have Apple repair the muffled audio/sound issue on Macbook with no warranty?


I just bought a used 2017 MBP15 with a larger SSD because my other 2017 MBP 15 was running out of space and found the one I just bought has this muffed audio issue. I got it for a good price from Craigslist so really want to keep it if Apple would make a courtesy repair - out of warranty.

Jul 31, 2019 1:36 PM in response to matt_90


Hello everyone from Russia! A year ago, I bought a macbook pro 15 with a touchbar. And today, as with many people, a small crackling sound was heard in the left column when the power was connected. Then everything is like everyone else. Some software solutions partially solve the problem, but in general, everything becomes backwards. But I want to say that here in Russia where there is no democracy and freedom of speech, we will not be able to influence APPLE. Therefore, I ask you my American colleagues to get them to make a return program! I work with video and when I come to clients I have to show video with sound, do I have to carry speakers with me? How do you imagine this Tim?

Sep 13, 2019 7:26 PM in response to matt_90

I am also having this problem with the Macbook Pro 2017 15". I tried changing the midi format hz but it's only a temporary fix. I am amazed how many people out here are having this problem. It this falling on deaf ears? I don't know how I can keep justifying spending this kind of money on these machines and having problems that aren't addressed. Apple, what can we do about this?

Oct 19, 2019 9:13 AM in response to matt_90

Same problem for me. I have a 15" Late 2016 MBP w/ Touch Bar, running macOS Catalina 10.15 (Up to date as of the writing of the post–I just installed the Oct. 15th supplemental update).


Often times, when I am watching a video on YouTube, the audio coming from the internal speakers will just randomly get "muffled", and stay that way for a period of time. I am not sure what causes it to happen or when/why it stops... and it doesn't seem to happen when I am streaming on a site like Netflix or Xfinity Stream though...? Very strange. I really need this fixed as the issue tends to flare up when I am at work. I need to play a videos at a decent-enough volume for everyone in our small office or in a small conference room to hear on a fairly regular basis and it's quite frustrating when the audio goes haywire halfway through–and stays that way.


Plus:


I am also having the issue that many others on this thread have referenced regarding the keys on the keyboard getting somewhat stuck or blocked... some keys, seemingly at random, will cease to have the amount of travel they are supposed to. With this keyboard, it's not like I can just easily use a pressurized air canister to push out any debris or dust that might be causing the issue like I used to on my 15" Early 2011 MBP. Dust or debris are likely the culprit because the problem is never permanent.


Additionally, I get an issue where keys tend to double tap even though I only hit them once (For example: every time I hit a given key, say the "b" key, I end up with "bb"). This issue tends to last on average for about a week.


Both of these keyboard issues are extremely frustrating... imagine typing in a password and not knowing if a keystroke is A. registering or not, or B. if one is doubling up on its own.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Volume triggered Muffled Speakers - 2016 MBP 15” Fault (w/ Video Demonstration)

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.