High Sierra Font Smoothing

It appears in High Sierra that font smoothing is inconsistently applied when disabled from System Preferences. Applications use a mix of smoothing and no-smoothing when the feature is disabled, my preference for Retina screens.


Text looks bad when one line is smoothed and another isn't.


Anyone else seeing this behavior?

Posted on Sep 28, 2017 11:00 AM

Reply
19 replies

Apr 1, 2018 5:42 AM in response to Clay Jones

I updated to 10.13.4 yesterday and the problem with wrong font smoothing seems to have been fixed with this release!

However I still experience issues with wrong language on pre-boot after updates if a firmware password has been set. If the password was disabled prior to applying updates (also minor updates like the additional one for 10.13.3 2 months ago) the language is set correctly if FileVault is enabled. (if someone else experienced issues with this in the past)

Summary for 10.13.4:

  • Font smoothing error is fixed for me so far
  • In case someone has problems with wrong language on login screen with FileVault enabled APFS volumes: disable firmware password protection prior to updates, then the language appears to be set correctly, I haven't found any workaround so far if no update can be done – with firmware password enabled it appears to always switch the login screen language to english. (In case anyone is wondering why to use firmware passwords – try resetting your NVRAM and then check if findmymac is still active, enable firmware passwords and try resetting NVRAM: it won't work and NVRAM reset simply disables findmymac which renders the feature pretty much completely useless, just a minor hint Apple doesn't seem to care telling customers about)

Dec 11, 2017 1:06 PM in response to Free 4 Live

Hello everyone,


I confirm that 10.13.2 is not solving this unexpected font smoothing with Finder's window in list or column view.


I also noticed that random smoothing font events occurred in third party application too. In this case, I didn't find a pattern as it exists for the Finder. I attached a screenshot from Tweetbot: Tweet with umlaut or accented characters are fine, font smoothing affects a message with "basic" letters (although I suspect it's the apostrophe fault).


I just remind you that Apple is not reading these discussions. Please do not forget to fill a bug report for this problem at bugreport.apple.com. (even Apple closes reports fast, a large number of reports about it may help to solve it in upcoming updates)


Regards.


User uploaded file

Oct 8, 2017 2:27 AM in response to Clay Jones

I'll just bump this a bit, adding that I already tried quite a lot to get this bug fixed. It seems that nothing helps. Though for me only stock macOS apps seem to be affected, most annoyingly in Finder. Some lines in list view are just bold and others not. Also I saw that on my sidebar (set to small fonts) the name of my MacBook will only be bold if the sidebar isn't wide enough to show the full name. Setting it to wide enough will make the boldness disappear, reverting to a tighter sidebar results in the font instantly becoming bold again. Changing width in any other affected app won't change anything.


Trying to fix I already tried enabling/disabling LCD font smoothing multiple times including switching with reboots and nvram/pram and smc resets in between rebooting. All to no avail. I'd also like to add, that I never had any problem like this in previous versions of Mac OS X/macOS (reaching back to 10.8).

Jan 25, 2018 5:05 AM in response to Clay Jones

macOS 10.13.3 (Build 17D47): the issue still has not been resolved for me. However, I recognized that one single folder does not seem to be affected. For the "public" folder, in german it is shown with a special character "ö" and is appearing as intended with disabled font smoothing. So, maybe a workaround would be, if we could apply the same for custom folders, to have them named differently than shown (after all, looking up default user folders in Terminal shows them in english, not like Finder's UI in local languages!). However, I don't know if that is either comfortable, or possible at all.

Jan 30, 2018 2:45 AM in response to Free 4 Live

Actually, for me it seems to have become even worse, texts which have not been "smoothed" before now appear smoothed, even in other apps than integrated ones, 1Password for example now applies text smoothing to truncated or special character texts as well, which it definitely didn't do before. Also, in system settings, there are some sentences smoothed now, which have not been before, while others, that also have special letters, still are not (like before).

I really wonder where this bug is going, I could even imagine Apple to be trying to force us to use this "feature" now, whatever the reason may be – but they often did in the past with features no one really wants to have after all. (Like the stupid idea to just be able to disconnect from wi-fi/bluetooth via control center on iOS instead of disabling the networking device, like it was prior to iOS 11 – who even asked for that or likes the idea!? Whats the purpose in that? This kind of makes control center useless like back when it wasn't there at all! (iOS 5, or was it even 4?))

Feb 9, 2018 2:19 PM in response to Tobit

And give access to data not everyone wants or should want to hand over willingly. On a privacy side, beta programs appear to possible be quite a two edged sword. Just keep that in mind before running for beta software from anyone


Aaaanyway, back to topic. Is it possible this bug comes from a graphics driver bug rather than a bug in metal or something else?

After all i found multiple reports of issues with Intel graphics in High Sierra (especially when it comes to games), so I was wondering if the error also exists on Macs running dedicated graphics ONLY (like in energy settings for laptop computers setting to always use discrete graphics)? Anyone capable of testing that?


Is there any final ETA on 10.13.4 yet? (For above mentioned reason, and some other, I clearly prefer using release OS over beta; I am kind of tired of (public) beta testing, especially when it comes to what Apple calls "beta")

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

High Sierra Font Smoothing

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.