Can't hear audio while recording Logic Pro X

Hey guys, For some reason i can't hear myself while recording on Logic Pro X using my Apogee Duet. For reference:

- I see the sound coming through on the Apogee

- I see it on the mixer

- I have input monitoring on

- I can hear it on playback but not while recording

Appreciate any help you can offer here, I've spent hours online trying to figure out what might be causing the issue to no avail. I've also added some photos for reference. Thank You!