Question: Phone still rings when connected to my watch
I have a Series 3 Apple watch and am using it with an iPhone 6S Plus (iOS 11.2.5). My phone used to automatically silence all notifications when connected to my watch and only my watch would vibrate. And when the two weren't paired, my phone would ring/chime as usual. But now when I receive a call or text, my phone rings/chimes even when paired with my watch. My watch still vibrates but my phone doesn't silence itself.
How do I get my phone to automatically silence itself again when paired with my watch?
Here are my watch settings:
Watch app > Notifications > Phone > Custom (checked), Show alerts (on), Sound (off), Haptic (on)
Thanks for your help.
Apple Watch Series 3, watchOS 4.2.2