Michael Black wrote:
Yes, but I don’t understand what your post has to do with the OP’s question?
The original question was whether the warranty was voided - which it is by any accidental damage. Whether a screen repair alone, or an out of warranty device replacement will fix the issue is independent of that simple fact.
I get that. However, the OP seems to be saying that they want to void the warranty on the LCD (if that's what meant by the "screen suddenly went black") because there's a crack in the glass. But since Apple only replaces it as an entire glass/LCD assembly, they're not going to replace it under warranty since there's accidental damage to part of that assembly. It wasn't clear if the OP understood that they're a combined part, which nobody else mentioned. Apple's policy has also been that they don't proceed with any repair (even a battery replacement) if the glass is accidentally cracked, unless the customer agrees to pay for a screen replacement service.
I guess an analogy would be if I installed RAM in my MacBook Pro while it was still under warranty but damaged one of the sockets during installation. If the GPU failed, they might deny a warranty replacement of the logic board because part of it (the RAM socket) was damaged by a user's accident.
Certainly the entire warranty isn't void. But they're not going to replace a user-damaged part (which the entire glass/LCD assembly is when just the glass is cracked) under warranty. They should be able to replace the entire assembly for the out of warranty price unless something else needs repair.