From what you’ve described, at some point, you were convinced to install garbage software. Or, you used an aggregate download site such as downloads.com or softonic.com. These sites do indeed offer all kinds of legal downloads to get free and shareware software from, or demos of commercial software. Problem is, many of those downloads also install adware. ChumSearch is currently one of the worst, as it’s difficult to remove.
You don’t need any type of AV software on a Mac. There are no viruses (software that installs with no help needed from the user). It’s all Trojans, which is software you have to download and install. No AV software can stop you from doing that.
Literally, every single piece of so-called anti this or that software in the App Store is 100% useless (as is all AV software not found there). The ones from the App Store are even more useless since to be included there for sale, such apps are severly restricted to what they can access on the drive. The only places they’re allowed to touch is within their own application package, and your user account.
The only exception to the above is MalwareBytes for Mac. It is not AV software. Its main purpose is to clean up after the fact. It does only two things in real time. One, it checks back to their site to see if there are any updates to apply. And two, it watches for ransomware. If such software attempts to encrypt data, MBAM will do it’s best to shut the app down as quickly as possible.