mac OS Mojave Won't Sleep

Immediately upon updating to Mojave, my iMac refuses to go to sleep. Up until the update, the computer went to sleep without issue. I've had the issue periodically (typically upon the release of a new OS), so I tend to keep a close watch for the issue.


I've tried all the recommendations (If your Mac doesn't sleep or wake when expected - Apple Support) made for those who encounter sleep issues (to no avail).


Activity Monitor indicates that something called "hidd" is included under the column "Preventing Sleep" (and this is the only item included in the column). Quitting the process is futile, since it automatically and instantly restarts itself.


Any tips?

macOS Mojave (10.14), null

Posted on Oct 13, 2018 5:28 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 16, 2019 7:12 AM

Hello All!

I've had the issue when I upgraded to Mojave on my work computer and then I began having the issue when I purchased my New Mac Mini just this December.

I found what was MY problem and I suggest everyone might check the same thing....

I had a 3rd party usb type-c extender hub to extend to a vga input, usb input, and c input.... It was this off-brand that was the culprit. After about an hour of trial and error unplugging each peripheral, I found that the extender I had my Apple External Superdrive plugged into was somehow waking it back up after 3 seconds. Once I removed that extender and plugged my Superdrive directly into the Mac Mini and sent it to sleep, it worked; went to sleep and stayed asleep until I touched the keyboard to wake it back up again after about 30 minutes.

I ran out and bought Apple recommended extenders to replace the previous ones I had both at home and for work.

Long story short: check your previous or new 3rd party extenders - Mojave may just not like them; ergo, they may not be optimized for Mojave. Use either Apple brand or other brands recommended from Apple's accessories lists; worth the extra bucks.

Hope this helps some folks.

29 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Jan 16, 2019 7:12 AM in response to Kimmi563tx

Hello All!

I've had the issue when I upgraded to Mojave on my work computer and then I began having the issue when I purchased my New Mac Mini just this December.

I found what was MY problem and I suggest everyone might check the same thing....

I had a 3rd party usb type-c extender hub to extend to a vga input, usb input, and c input.... It was this off-brand that was the culprit. After about an hour of trial and error unplugging each peripheral, I found that the extender I had my Apple External Superdrive plugged into was somehow waking it back up after 3 seconds. Once I removed that extender and plugged my Superdrive directly into the Mac Mini and sent it to sleep, it worked; went to sleep and stayed asleep until I touched the keyboard to wake it back up again after about 30 minutes.

I ran out and bought Apple recommended extenders to replace the previous ones I had both at home and for work.

Long story short: check your previous or new 3rd party extenders - Mojave may just not like them; ergo, they may not be optimized for Mojave. Use either Apple brand or other brands recommended from Apple's accessories lists; worth the extra bucks.

Hope this helps some folks.

Jan 16, 2019 7:30 AM in response to JohnPaulWilliam

Hello All!

I've had the issue when I upgraded to Mojave on my work computer and then I began having the issue when I purchased my New Mac Mini just this December.

I found what was MY problem and I suggest everyone might check the same thing....

I had a 3rd party usb type-c extender hub to extend to a vga input, usb input, and c input.... It was this off-brand that was the culprit. After about an hour of trial and error unplugging each peripheral, I found that the extender I had my Apple External Superdrive plugged into was somehow waking it back up after 3 seconds. Once I removed that extender and plugged my Superdrive directly into the Mac Mini and sent it to sleep, it worked; went to sleep and stayed asleep until I touched the keyboard to wake it back up again after about 30 minutes.

I ran out and bought Apple recommended extenders to replace the previous ones I had both at home and for work.

Long story short: check your previous or new 3rd party extenders - Mojave may just not like them; ergo, they may not be optimized for Mojave. Use either Apple brand or other brands recommended from Apple's accessories lists; worth the extra bucks.

Hope this helps some folks.


....ooops... sorry for the extra post.

Apr 15, 2019 4:09 PM in response to JohnPaulWilliam

A bit late to this thread, but wanted to share how I solved the same problem... after upgrading to Mojave from High Sierra yesterday, I notice fan was on and in fact my 2012 MBP would not go to sleep by closing the lid or selecting sleep from the apple menu (the screen would go to sleep and then immediately come on again). Contacted Apple Care, after quite some time on the phone checking Activity Monitor, resetting SMC and PRAM having not solved the problem, we noticed that in System Preferences: Sharing, the Screen Sharing box was ticked to on. After unticking, ie switching screen sharing to off, the problem was resolved and the computer now sleeps. The Apple Care representative was surprised by this, said he had learnt something new! There didn’t seem to be any info as to this solution in the knowledge base. It seems there is no one fix for this problem but hope this may solve some people’s issue

Dec 4, 2018 10:05 PM in response to JohnPaulWilliam

I was experiencing the same thing, the session would lock, but the screen would not sleep. Mine is a Mac Pro with two monitors, an Apple LED Cinema Display and a Thunderbolt Display. My USB keyboard was connected through the Cinema Display. Setting the display sleep as low as it could go and selecting "Lock Screen" from the Apple menu would lock the screen, and after a short time (30 seconds, maybe a minute) it would try to turn off the two displays then immediately turn them back on. Every 30 seconds or so it would repeat the cycle.


Moving the keyboard from the Cinema Display to the Mac Pro itself resolved the problem for me. Apparently, something in the display sleep triggered a USB event that the keyboard responded to, and the Mac would interpret the keyboard's response as a wake-up.


I don't know if the USB in your iMac is wired as part of the Mac or part of the display. That is, is the iMac essentially a USB-enabled display with a Mac attached to it, or a USB Mac with a display attached to it? Experimenting with what is plugged in to the iMac may help. It may not give you the resolution you're looking for, but maybe you can pinpoint the cause.


There is an app called Wimoweh that helps manage sleep, can block sleep itself if it sees certain processes running, or if the CPU load is over a certain amount, and can set a sleep timer. More importantly, it will list all the processes that are preventing sleep and say why sleep is prevented. The hidd process shows up in my Wimoweh display with an assertion type of "UserIsActive." When you stop using the keyboard and mouse for a while, the hidd process should release the assertion. It's presence in Activity Monitor is normal.

Apr 24, 2019 8:35 AM in response to JohnPaulWilliam

My Mac mini sleep problem started when I upgraded to 10.14.4. It would not sleep, ever. I tried without success, almost everything suggested in this thread and others. Then, I remembered something from previous versions of Mac OS. The slider will not allow Computer Sleep before Screen Sleep.


Assertions in Terminal.app verify my Screen Sleep setting of 10 minutes (600 seconds).


mini:~ earl$ pmset -g assertions

2019-04-24 10:50:49 -0400

Assertion status system-wide:

.....zero items snipped.....

UserIsActive 1

.....zero items snipped.....

Listed by owning process:

pid 112(hidd): [0x00001f1f00098576] 00:00:00 UserIsActive named: "com.apple.iohideventsystem.queue.tickle.4294969512.3"

Timeout will fire in 600 secs Action=TimeoutActionRelease

.....remaining lines snipped.....


But, Mojave has no slider for Computer Sleep. What is the setting and how is it changed?


I checked the current Computer Sleep setting. This was the problem.


mini:~ earl$ sudo systemsetup -getcomputersleep

Computer Sleep: after 1 minutes


I changed the Computer Sleep setting to 15 minutes. The range of allowable values is 0-100.


mini:~ earl$ sudo systemsetup -setcomputersleep 15

setcomputersleep: 15


I verified the new setting.


mini:~ earl$ sudo systemsetup -getcomputersleep

Computer Sleep: after 15 minutes


Problem solved, at least for me. This fixed both Automatic Sleep and Manual Sleep.


Automatic Sleep.

Screen Saver - 5 minutes

Screen Sleep - 10 minutes

Computer Sleep - 15 minutes


Manual Sleep.

Screen Sleep - immediately

Computer Sleep - about 1 minute


Now, I have to turn on all the stuff I turned off in search of a solution.

Oct 13, 2018 5:38 AM in response to JohnPaulWilliam

The process hidd is the Human Interface Device Daemon. It is required for your Mac to operate properly. It controls mouse, trackpad, keyboard. I'm not sure why it is listed under Preventing Sleep.

Sleep issues are some of the most difficult to troubleshoot. Here's what Apple has to say:

If your Mac doesn't sleep or wake when expected - Apple Support

FWIW, I gave up on the Sleep function years ago. Ever since the inception of OS X there have been Sleep related issues. And even more lately. I just use Display Sleep and keep it set for 15 minutes so I'm not burning the screen. That way your Mac uses very little power over Sleep and is ready to use at the touch of a key without any grogginess. UNIX based systems were made to be always on and they’ve been running busy servers 24/7 for decades.

Oct 13, 2018 5:54 AM in response to macjack

Thanks, macjack.


You did see that I had already linked to the advice Apple provides, didn't you? Excuse my bringing the point up, but whenever one re-posts information which was provided in an initial post, I can only (and justifiably) assume that the entire post was not read.


As per giving up on the sleep function, I'm an advocate of the idea that using less energy is preferable to using more energy. If Apple wants to present itself as bastions of ecological stewards, they had better actually walk the walk.


Thanks for your help.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

mac OS Mojave Won't Sleep

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.