MiniDV Camera with Video-In

I'm in the market for a new digital video camera. In addition to the normal chores of recording new video, I'd like this to be able to do the double-duty of assisting me in importing to digital format my VHS collection. I've often read that many digital video cameras have a video-in port that a VCR can be plugged into for this purpose, but I have not yet been able to discover which cameras include this. Having no luck on the web, I visited a local brick-and-mortar store, but they didn't carry any cameras with that capability, although they mentioned that they used to.

I would prefer to use a camera that uses the MiniDV tape format. If anyone has any specific recommendations, or if you can inform me how to figure out if a particular camera has this feature, I would very much appreciate it.

MacBook Pro Mac OS X (10.4.8) 1GB RAM/120GB HD

Posted on Mar 11, 2007 6:41 PM

Reply
6 replies

Mar 11, 2007 8:45 PM in response to Charles Ross

Hello Charles,

it's difficult to point you to a specific model here. Various camcorder models have this feature (usually called A/V in or A/V input) that allows you to use the camera as an analog/digital pass-through device.
That said, IMHO you should select various cameras that appeal to you in terms of shooting video, then check the price category. Once you have narrowed it down you can check if they accept A/V in.

A good place to start is www.camcorderinfo.com - lots of good reviews here.

I personally like Sony, but Panasonic and Canon make good camcorders to.

hope this helps

mish

Mar 11, 2007 8:49 PM in response to Charles Ross

Sony camcorders are known to work well with iMovie.

You just need to make sure whatever brand/model you choose has a "pass through feature" which allows you to connect to an analog source (using composite/S-video cable) pass it through your camcorder and into your computer/iMovie via firewire cable.

Many low end models may not have analog input ports or an Analog-to-Digital Converter(with Pass Through)feature, so beware.

I wouldn't spend a lot of money on a Standard Definition mini DV camcorder now. High Definition will be the De Facto in a year or so.

The bottom line: you first want to make sure the mini DV cam has analog (composite/s-video)input ports.

Then look for the "pass thru feature".

With it you can record from the VHS/DVD player straight into iMovie using the camcorder acting as a bridge between the the player and computer.

Without this feature you will first have to record to tape then import the tape into iMovie.

Do your research.
There are plenty models from Sony, Canon, panasonic, etc. that have been discontinued and won't appear on the website, but you can find them on Amazon.com or similar sites. If you find one with the features you need it'll save you a couple hundred dollars.

I use an old Sony Digital8 310 camcoder (circa 1999) for this very same purpose (it still shoots decent video for a 1 chip camcorder).

Like I said I won't spend a lot of money on a Standard Definition cam at this point in time. The High Definiton era is just over the horizon.

Mar 12, 2007 1:23 PM in response to Charles Ross

Thanks to both of the responses to my original post, I was able to ask the right questions. I still didn't find the information easily on the web. Some manufacturers make this information easy to find and others don't. I was surprised to find no master database of camcorder features that would allow me to specify the features I was interested in and get a list of camcorders that satisfy my requirements. Regardless, I ended up calling the manufacturers to get my final answers regarding if a particular model had the needed features. I ended up ordering a refurbished Samsung SC-D365.

Mar 12, 2007 8:55 PM in response to Charles Ross

Charles,

I paid a visit to the Samsung support site and here's what I got.
Recording From An External Device

The following Models can be used as a recorder to record from a VCR, TV or another Camcorder.
2004 - SC-D107
2003 - SC-D5000, SC-D27
2002 - SC-D180


http://erms.samsungusa.com/customer/sea/jsp/faqs/faqsview.jsp?PG_ID=3&AT_ID=17600&PROD_SUB_ID=44&PRODID=167

Can I Use My DV Camcorder As A Pass Through Device Connecting A PC And Another Source To It?
None of our DV camcorders can pass through a signal from another source (VCR, TV, DVD player) to a PC

http://erms.samsungusa.com/customer/sea/jsp/faqs/faqsview.jsp?PG_ID=3&AT_ID=5813&PROD_SUB_ID=44&PRODID=167


I think you will be disappointed with the camcorder's features and it received very low marks for picture quality on a number of review sites.

I agree with Matthew "You can't go wrong with Sony". That Sony DCR-HC96 looks pretty sweet. I would recommend returning the Samsung if you can.

Here's a Sony DCRHC30 MiniDV ($309) with all the features you need and should be comparable in price to the Samsung
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0001BVXJK/ref=olpproductdetails/002-1209763-2528833?ie=UTF8&seller=

Samsung is really at the bottom of the list for mini Dv camcorders.

Mar 13, 2007 6:25 AM in response to Charles Ross

The selection of MiniDV cameras of any kind is dwindling quickly. It's very disappointing, in my opinion. My criteria was very similar to yours: analog video input and MiniDV. I just purchased a Canon ZR-700 (a 2005 model, I believe) from B&H Photo. It's been superseded by the Elura 100 (now discontinued), which was in turn superseded by the ZR850. The ZR850 no longer supports video input (aka pass-through). To the best of my knowledge, this means that there are no current models that support analog video-in in Canon's non-HD linup, and most other manufacturers seem to not provide that feature on their lower-end consumer models. The research I've done (mainly via camcorderinfo.com) indicates that Panasonics have the best video quality (with their 3CCD chip), followed roughly by Canon and then Sony. The Panasonic cameras in my price range (sub $500) don't do video-in, and the reviews of the Sonys were unfavorable enough that I wasn't interested in even looking at them.

Just my two cent rant. Good luck with your project!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

MiniDV Camera with Video-In

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.