Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

New MacPro, Logic Pro, RAID and streaming files for a sampler.

I’m setting up a MacPro to use with Logic Pro and Ableton Live. The primary use for this computer is music creation above all else. After reading recommendations on this forum I ordered the basic 4x2.66 and pulled the included memory and hard drive, replacing them with 4x1Gig memory chips and 4x500Gig WD5000YS hard drives. After spending 8 hours installing the OS, Logic Pro and some other software I realized that I forgot to consider RAID. Because the my main concern is streaming samples and loops along with writing output I think I will be fine leaving one 500Gig HD as the boot drive and setting up the other three drives in Raid 0. I do have a question on this setup.

Should I accept the default setups when I create the RAID or should I tweak block size to handle special needs for music creation? While some of the audio files on output will be quite large, the nature of a streaming sampler is to read the beginning of every sample file. Example, while a piano has 88 keys a good sample set for that piano will multiple samples at different velocities for each key. The software will load the beginning of every sample into memory, and when a note is played it will start playing the note in memory and immediately load the rest of the samples for that note into memory. We are talking a lot of files open and a lot of quick reads to avoid glitches.

Any suggestions on how to best set up my RAID for lots of multiple files to be read rather than dealing with very large individual files?

Thanks

Intel MacMini & MacBook Pro C2D 17" 2 Gig & MacMini Duo 2 Gig & 80 Gig iPod G5, Mac OS X (10.4.9)

Posted on Apr 23, 2007 3:55 PM

Reply
4 replies

Apr 23, 2007 5:07 PM in response to DJRabid

I've read and talked to some audio pros that use either very high-end Fibre Channel controllers and array, and go with a Concatenated RAID to reduce latency and avoid splitting a file across drives.

Might want to boot from 5th drive even and use the 4 drives as some type of RAID. If you take a file and try to split it across 3 or 4 drives, you do need larger block sizes in order, in part, to avoid splitting a file as often.

Apr 30, 2007 9:59 AM in response to DJRabid

Thanks for the help. I finally decided on this setup.

Drive 1 - Boot drive. Big enough to install Logic Pro and my instruments.

Drive 2 and 3 - RAID 0, used for audio data and streaming files. All media will go on this drive.

Drive 4 - Am going to test it as a secondary boot drive using Parallels' Desktop and Windows Vista. I don't want Windows on my main boot drive in any form. This will give me an opportunity to install some software like MSOffice and Streets and Trips.

If that does not work out then Drive 4 will be designated as either backup or for output when I finalize songs.

Jul 17, 2007 2:18 PM in response to DJRabid

hi

i also use logic pro

i did the same as you (only nothing in drive no.4)

logic's project manager sees the audio files in proper raid volume, but not the songs. songs do exist in finder and i can load them, but not in project manager

is this your case?

thanks

Mac Pro 2 X 2.66 GHz Dual Core Intel Xeon 4G RAM, 250G + 2 X 500G RAID 0 Mac OS X (10.4.8) Logic Pro (7.2.3) MOTU 828mkII

New MacPro, Logic Pro, RAID and streaming files for a sampler.

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.