Minimum size/maximum quality MP3 sound file balance

My first objective when creating MP3 files is to compress the sound file as much as possible, and I don't want any file to exceed 1MB, if possible. (One exception was compressing a 30 minute poetry recitation into a 1.8 MB file.) That turned out okay, but music is another story. So, I'd like to know more about how to strike a satisfactory balance between size and quality. For the iTunes MP3 import settings,this means choosing between (1) STEREO BIT RATES (16kbps to 320 kbps), (2) QUALITY (Low to Highest), and (3) CHANNEL (mono or stereo)

In the past, I have always chosen mono, but it now occurs to me that the quality enhancement of stereo might justify the larger files caused by slightly higher kbps settings. That's just one example. Anyway, I'd like to read an article on the trade-offs between the variables that iTunes provides. Any
suggestions?

MacBook, 2 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, Mac OS X (10.4.9)

Posted on Apr 25, 2007 10:25 AM

Reply
9 replies

Apr 25, 2007 10:38 AM in response to Niku

If you want small files and max sound quality, use AAC instead of MP3.

You aren't gonna get songs down to 1 MB with any quality at all.

iTunes uses 128 kbps AAC as the default because it is about the best compromise between quality and size.
This works out to ~1MB per minute.

Audio files (lectures and podcasts and such) can be set to 32k/64k stereo with great results since the frequency range is not as great as with music. This works out to 10MB per hour

Apr 25, 2007 10:57 AM in response to Chris CA

If you want small files and max sound quality, use
AAC instead of MP3.


But isn't the AAC format only for Macs? Most of the people I send files to have PCs, and I don't like receiving messages saying that they couldn't open the file I sent them.

Another question: What is STEREO BIT RATE? Whenever people use the term kbps, are they referring to STEREO BIT RATE, or is it another measure, perhaps a more basic, more important one? In my experience, the term STEREO BIT RATE doesn't occur very frequently. You see recommended kbps speeds, but STEREO BIT RATE doesn't seem to come up that often. A word of clarification would be appreciated.

Apr 25, 2007 11:10 AM in response to Niku

Stereo Bit Rate is what people are talking about when they say that a song is XXX kbps. (kbps is a measure of bit-rate, a measure of kilobytes per second).

Stereo v. Mono really depends on what type of song you are sampling, and what you are listening to it on. For virtually all music recorded after 1970, though, you'd probably want to use Stereo.

Also, you might get some mileage by making sure that you are importing the music at 41.100 kHz rather than using Auto or 48.000. (This is basically the "speed" at which the music is sampled. The faster its sampled, the more information it contains. It makes it higher quality, but also higher file size. You probably won't notice too much difference between 41.1 and 48.)

Finally, you should also check the Variable Bit Rate box. This will help reduce the file size, as the bit rate will be reduced during silences and other times where the song doesn't need more information.

As for the overall Bit Rate, its really subjective. Your best bet is to just try it at a few different levels and decide which is best for you.

Apr 25, 2007 11:40 AM in response to Niku

But isn't the AAC format only for Macs?
No.

Most of the people I send files to have PCs,
Well, I hope you aren't sending them copyrighted songs (RIP'd from CDs or purchases).

What is STEREO BIT RATE?
The bit rate is how many bits per second are being used in the file. It can be stereo or mono. Stereo uses two channels (left & right), mono uses one (combines them).

In my experience, the term STEREO BIT RATE doesn't occur very frequently.
It's not usually mentioned because music is in almost always stereo.

If you are doing voice, narration and such, it's better to use mono because
a - you don't need stereo
b - the resulting file size will be significantly smaller

Apr 25, 2007 11:51 AM in response to Yer_Man

But isn't the AAC format only for Macs?

No. It's actually the next generation mp3, is an
industry standard.

---------
Okay, thanks. And thanks to Dan F, too, because I hadn't noticed that link. I had just thought it was some kind of visual static. I'll have to be more alert to such things in the future, because I now realize that I have made the same mistake many times in the past and missed who knows what as a result.

Apr 25, 2007 12:00 PM in response to Chris CA

What is STEREO BIT RATE?
The bit rate is how many bits per second are being
used in the file. It can be stereo or mono. Stereo
uses two channels (left & right), mono uses one
(combines them).

--------------
Thanks for the amplification. I was confused about how the term STEREO could also apply to mono recordings and had even typed a message asking about that, but somehow lost it. Before I could type it again, I saw your comments. I still think it's a misuse of language, though. Well, I'll live with it. It took me a couple of years before I could accept the way the word "default" is used in the computer world, but I finally succumbed, and now I use it that way myself.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Minimum size/maximum quality MP3 sound file balance

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.