inCase - Rubber Case Question

Hello,

I've seen a few posts about this, but just wanted to make sure I interpreted it correctly. Was at the apple store yesterday and of all the cases, the genius bar iPhone person recommended the rubber inCase when I asked him, he also said it was the most popular among his colleagues. So I bought it.

I got home and have seen a ton of posts claiming the case actually makes things worse and causing scratching. Can anyone that has used one comment on this? I also picked up some of the plastic screen protectors, but after putting one on took it right off, I didn't like it, it seemed to get dirtier, and i could never get it on straight. Sorta bummed if i spent 45 bucks on two products i can't use, wanted some opinions. Thanks

iMac Core Duo, 2Ghz; Macbook 2.0 Core 2 Duo, Mac OS X (10.4.8)

Posted on Jul 15, 2007 2:18 PM

Reply
39 replies

Jul 18, 2007 6:46 AM in response to Azeroth

I have the same problem with the incase, i never checked for scratches until i started reading the threads.And there are scratches around the chrome or should i same plome (plastic chrome).I can live with it though out of sight out of mind.If my OCD kicks in i might try to remove the scrathes with some of the methods mentioned.I also tried those crystal film protecters i would guess that they work good if you can get them on without getting a single piece of dust on it.Or if you have the ability of not touching the underside of them.I tried both that come in the package and threw them both out.One of them had scratches already on it that you could see once i put it on.The other one got a piece of dust on it and it was over for me.I would by another set only if i can build a clean room or something and wear a suit.I also found out that Monster cleaner for lcd sceens works great on the iphone.It comes with a micro-fiber cloth with the spray bottle.

Jul 18, 2007 7:24 AM in response to igrok-mac

Apparently none of you ever owned an iPod.

My 3G iPod had a beautiful chrome back that could have been used as a mirror...for about 30 seconds. After that it was pure swirl marks and scratches. I set it down on a table 10 minutes after I got the thing and when I picked it back up, it was covered in scratches.

My opinion is to protect the phone, not the way the phone looks. A beautiful phone that won't turn on because you dropped it without a case is not much of a phone at all.

Jul 21, 2007 10:58 AM in response to TenaciousN8

I am going to keep it caseless until iSkin releases the
revo case and see how that holds up.


iSkin revo looks like a pretty neat (and well thought out case). However, I wonder if dust/grit trapped between the "visor" polycarbonate screen protector and the glass will actually cause scratches on the glass similar to how other protectors are causing scratches on the chrome. Go to the beach, get a little grit in between, and bye-bye screen.

Jul 21, 2007 11:15 AM in response to Azeroth

first off i do have this case. It is great, provides protection and is a good non slip surface for the phone. I never gave a thought to scratching until reading something on iphoneatlas this morning and seeing this thread. Examined my pjlhone amd have no scratching. Would recomend the case.

But this seems like a bunch of whining to me. Come on its aphone not a piece of art. I hope in a year mine shows to wear and tear expected for a device i use continually

Jul 21, 2007 10:02 PM in response to mjworks@mac.com

I'm using the Incase rubber sleeve and like it a lot - no scratches so far. I think black looks cool and I like the added protection from a drop.

I am going to try to use a Scotch-Brite pad and give the chrome bezel a dull, matte finish because I think it will look better and not show scratches as much when the iPhone is uncased.

If the bezel is scratching so easily and people are having luck with Never-Dull polishing out fine scratches, I think the chrome surface may take well to a Scotch-Brite "refinishing". The question is, how thick is the chrome layer? I'm pretty sure the bezel is real metal as this is the only part of the iPhone that "did not blend" in the Blendtec video!

I think I will use painter's blue tape on the glass and plastic back and have at the chrome with a Scotch-Brite! Perhaps smooth, continuous strokes around the chrome frame will create fine linear scratches for the proper look.

BTW, I have used Scotch-Brite pads on magnesium alloys and aluminum to create a really nice matte finish.

I'll let you guys know how it turns out.

Best,

Kurt

MacBook Pro, iMac, iPhone Mac OS X (10.4.10)

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

inCase - Rubber Case Question

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.