Are you sure that both these macs are getting IP addresses from the same place? (1 wired, 1 wireless...might mean that mac2 is getting neighbor's wifi)
Are you certain that this trouble mac is configured to be fully Automatic in the NetworkSystemPreferences?
"Conigure IPv4...Using DHCP" ( not manually, not dhcp with manual address, not bootP...)
Have you done a cold start to all your network devices (macs, router, modem, network printers?)
Power-cycle them off. Count 2 minutes. Start up modem, pause. Start up router/BaseStation, pause. Start up mac(s).
You haven't said what kind of router/baseStation you've got. 'Twould help, maybe.
added: Do you have a wireless modem/router AND a wireless airportBS/router/something)?
Message was edited by: Rick Van Vliet
Message was edited by: Rick Van Vliet