I have 3 computers at home all of which I upgraded using the "Upgrade Install"..
The permissions for the User files and folders were mostly all set to "unknown" group...
This wasn't really a big deal for me in itself because I really didn't need to change permissions of a particular folder. However, I did reinstall Leopard using Archive and Install without saving user settings on one of my computers. It just bugged me... (In fact, I have installed Leopard about 6 times on my external HD in all the different ways just to see how the permissions were handled.)
The permissions were set correctly doing it this way as long as the files and folders were not migrated from Tiger.
It would be a real pain to do all the computers this way like you mention. Very time consuming.
In your office situation, I am not sure if some of the folder permissions would hinder you any.
There is a temporary fix for user permissions from Apple:
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=307128
For me, I don't think the average user wants to go through all the above. They just want to turn on their machines and go. They don't want to even know about permissions or how the computer works, they just want it to work.
If you have a cloned copy of your Tiger system, I would try using the Upgrade Install and see if it works for you... If it doesn't, you can always put your cloned copy back and think about the next step....
SuperDuper...
Yes, great for 10.4 and below.
Thanks for the clarification...
All my machines are running Leopard so I can't use SuperDuper at this time.
Haven't had any problems with Carbon Copy Cloner at all though....