Good morning, Tbonedaprodigy, Ok, my opinion (because I own two defender cases-the two different colors) is that OB is best. I prefer the more rugged Defender case because it protects the phone all around including the screen. It has a clear thin membrane attached to the case that protects the screen and allows full usage of the screen. In addition, the silicone jacket offers grip as well as additional protection. It's not fully waterproof, but it does protect the phone from light precipitation. No dust or dirt gets in either.
I've said it before, what good is a "prettier case" or a much thinner case if it doesn't protect the phone well? Plus the defender doesn't really add that much bulk, in my opinion. I use it regularly with the holster, but when I don't and put it in my pocket, it's not too bulky.
If you decide to order one and find you really don't like it, you can return it. OB's customer service is awesome.
Hope this helps.
iPhoNettie
Message was edited by: iPhoNettie