FCE 3.5.1 HD hangs when I start up with my Panasonic NV-GS200 camcorder connect via firewire. I have tried firewire DV PAL, Firewire basic PAL etc with no effect. FCE will only load if I turn off the camcorder. iMovie '08 stops at the blue importing video screen if it recognises the camera and iChat AV 4.0.2 does not recognise the camera or freezes. My OS 10.5.2 is fairly vanilla with all the recommended updates from Apple. Quicktime is up to date as is Flip4Mac WMV. The only other firewire device connected is an external HDD but both powering down and disconnecting the device has no impact. I have used a couple of different firewire cables, used the front firewire port, the back port and the port on my 20" Apple Cinema Display. I have an early (2006) Mac Pro 2 x 2.66GHz dual-core Intel Xeon with 2 GB RAM and 3 x 500GB internal HDD and ATI Radeon X1900XT.
The camcorder works fine with iMovie '08 on my new MacBook Pro 2.6GHz (Nov 2007) and on an old 1.25GHz eMac running 10.4.11. I can capture video if I boot into MS Vista under Boot Camp on my Mac Pro using MovieMaker.
This is very frustrating. The camera and cable combination works well on every machine I have tested except my Mac Pro under 10.5.2. The camera had worked previously on the machine under Tiger but I haven't used FCE for the last 8-12 months. A google search indicates sporadic mention of similar issues but with no solutions. I would appreciate any help if someone has resolved this issue.
Mac Pro,
Mac OS X (10.5.2),
2 x 2.66GHz Dual-Core Intel Xeon, 2GB RAM
Weird thing is I was looking through some old postings about firewire issues on Mac Pros and came across turning off firewire networking. I did this and it had no effect, hoever I turned on my external firewire HDD and hey presto, FCE recognises my camcorder. iChat AV also works. Turn off the drive and nothing works.
It appears from what you say that there is either a problem with your Mac or more likely with some of the updates you have done recently, rather than the camera.
Over the last year certain QT updates have caused FCE problems, though I haven't heard of iMovie being similarly affected.
Could you install FCE on your MBP and try that ? If your MBP has identical updates it will probably show the same problem, but if it did work it might give a few more clues.
Also would it be possible to try another camera just to rule out that it is not your Panasonic that is at fault?
If anyone else has any positive ideas please chime in !
I'm having problems too, in this area.
I think it is to do with having FCE and Imovie both active.
My DV camcorder wont work with FCE or Imovie at present via firewire. I took it all into the genius bar and they made it work by applying the correct 'easy' settings in FCE. I brought it all home and neither works. Imovie won't even open a window.
I'm going to try applecare tomorrow and will post any helpful hints up here
Just re-re-reading the experience above: in the shop they had another drive attached to the firewire port as well as my camera. I don't have this at home !
The problem is sort of resolved in that I can use my camera but I do not understand why. Normally the issues with firewire have been about having another firewire device active at the same time and hence why I normally turn off the drive. My problem seems to be the opposite. The drive has to be turned on for the camera to be recognised.
No the camera is connected to either the front or back firewire port. The external HDD is connected to the port on the back of my Apple Cinema Display.
This thread has been closed by the system or the community team.
You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.
FCE 3.5.1 Mac Pro and Panasonic NV-GS200
Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.