Hi macjack,
You're definitely right that ACL's are somehow to blame for this mess. I got my new MacPro set up, and then hooked up my Powerbook G4 in target disk mode, to see if I could back the laptop up using Time Machine on the desktop. This failed, because I did not have adequate permissions to see my files on the laptop. So I made the (horrendously stupid) decision to take ownership of my laptop hard drive and apply the ownership change to all enclosed folders. Next thing I knew, I no longer had access to any of the files on my laptop. Period.
Two weeks later, after numerous reinstalls of Leopard on both the laptop and the tower, I nearly have the systems running again. I have managed to re-establish access to nearly all of my files using fsaclctl, but I've still got two annoying legacy problems. On the laptop, at startup a file called "step_3.gif" automatically opens in Preview, and on the tower (relevant to this thread), I can no longer drag and drop files from anywhere, to anywhere.
Revisiting the threads above,
(0) I can highlight files by clicking on them, but dragging does not move them at all.
(1) I can use the command line in Terminal to mv a file on and off the desktop. Finder is the problem.
(2) Deleting com.apple.finder.plist had no discernible effect.
(3) The permissions on my home directory seem to make sense (I have rw, system has ro, everyone has ro).
(4) Rebuilding LaunchServices didn't solve the problem.
(5) ls -le shows "0: group:everyone deny delete" for everything in my home directory, so the ACLs are still screwed up.
(6) Trying to reset permissions for each folder manually does not have any effect.
(7) Conniff's solution (running Reset Password from the install disk, and then repairing the Permissions and ACLs on my home folder) had no effect.
The only other symptom that I can contribute to the thread is three warnings I get when I start up regarding CHUDsomething-or-others.kext that failed to load because of (you guessed it) inadequate permissions.
Altogether, I'm furious with Apple over this problem: Time Machine seemed like a good idea, but this **** ACL problem has been my least pleasant operating system experience since DOS. I can't remember when I last had to completely format and reinstall my system, much less failed to fix the problems by doing so. At least the reinstall has allowed me to run "Repair Disk Permissions", but that apparently doesn't help with screwed up ACL's on my home folder. Until my OS behaves properly, I won't trust my backups, so I feel like I'm operating without a net and it is driving me nuts.
Chris