Anyone using Stylus RMX with Logic? Do you understand "grooves"?

I got a copy of Stylus RMX and am trying to get my head around it. In particular, I'm trying to figure out how to get more than one groove on a single track.

For example, I'd like to have 4 beats of one groove followed by 4 beats of a related groove, then another, and so on.

However, I've discovered that once I have dragged a single groove on to a track (which looks like it created a region with MIDI data in it), then if I click on another groove in Stylus RMX, the region I previously dragged into a drag seems to now trigger the NEW groove, and the old one is lost.

It's as if those regions do nothing more than trigger whatever groove is currently selected for the length of the region.

I don't see how I can create a full track and get multiple grooves on it. I understand how to create up to 8 separate tracks, each on a different channel and assign a different groove (in RMX) to each channel but that would still only gives me 8 grooves, and I would have to waste 8 tracks to do this.

There must be a better way but I can't see it.

The knowledgebase on their site is not helpful. The video tutorial for drag/drop seems to only have one groove per track as well. This seems like a very serious limitation. What am I missing?


Thanks,
David

Mac OS X (10.5.4)

Posted on Jul 12, 2008 8:00 PM

Reply
21 replies

Jul 13, 2008 5:42 AM in response to dhjdhj

It doesn't work that way.

Just think about it for a minute... a groove is sliced and diced, and the MIDI data is then available to drop onto your DAW to be able to play back that groove at any tempo.

But if you switch to a different loop, the MIDI data present no longer is playing the proper sounds.

It's not a limitation of the software... it's how you're trying to use it.

If you simply want a "variation" of the groove every 4 or 8 bars, you can edit the MIDI data to rearrange the slices that are available in a loop, to create a whole different groove, or feel (using the same sounds, of course).

You can also use more than 1 RMX instance. If you have a sufficient amount of RAM, you could easily add 3, 4, or more RMX's, all doing their thing.

So if you had 4 RMX's working in multi-timbral mode, you could effectively have 32 variances of a single groove available to you.

Jul 13, 2008 6:14 AM in response to dhjdhj

Stylus RMX is Awesome...

ALL Spectrasonics Instruments are the best that you can find...
you can listen it in the most recent Hollywood movies, FOX TV and other productions

Spectrasoncs V.I. are Awesome and they are the first reason to make me sure that I never sell My PPC Mac until Spectrasonics Atmosphere and Trilogy cannot be compatible... (I never sell Mac at ALL IN ANY CASE 🙂 )

I'm stay on my PPC Dual G5... it is a Rock solid piece of original Apple/IBM Hardware!

but... you got a copy????

what do you say???

I think you need to buy it before talking about!

G

Jul 13, 2008 8:28 AM in response to Jim Frazier

I had assumed that those "grooves" were actually MIDI patterns and therefore I could just drag different patterns on to a single track, and have those patterns triggering drum high-quality drum samples in RMX.

Even GarageBand lets me drop multiple "grooves" on a single track, one after the other.

I understand from your explanation and from subsequent experiments I did after posting the original question how RMX is working but I find it quite unintuitive, particularly because of the drag-drop mechanism. I had expected the drag-drop procedure to make a COPY of whatever groove was currently selected in RMX, particularly since there WAS midi data in the newly created region. I didn't expect it to just be an alias to the selection!

Do any of the other drum tools available work the way I want? I looked at the DrumCore website, for example, but they don't make it clear what they're doing either.

What I'd really love is a Mac version of Jamstix and I suppose I could setup a VM in the Mac, or run a Windows box with MIDI/Audio over Ethernet but I really don't want to HAVE to go that route.

Jul 13, 2008 8:49 AM in response to dhjdhj

dhjdhj wrote:
Even GarageBand lets me drop multiple "grooves" on a single track, one after the other.


That's because it's playing an audio file, non-dependent of samples loaded into RAM. And if it is a MIDI file, the "drumset" sound loaded has all the elements (kick, snare, TOMS, etc...) to create a fill or groove variance without the actual soundbank changing.

But I do understand what it is you're trying to accomplish. RMX, for as cool, and powerful as it is, isn't designed to replace a real drummers performance. Even Eric Persings will tell you that.

It sounds like you would benefit from acidized "drag & Drop" audio files. These are audio files, that will follow the tempo of your sequencer. You can drag a 8 bar loop onto the arrange page, followed by a 1 bar fill, then onto a different variance of the groove, another fill, etc... song construction type stuff.

I use Discrete Drums for this type of thing, for the vary reason you stated. Programming drums is my least favorite chore in all of production... especially when trying to emulate REAL drums. Life's too short... 🙂

http://www.discretedrums.com/

But I'd encourage you not to blame RMX. It is one of the most powerful loop based tools around. But a loop by definition is a repetitive performance. You are looking for something beyond that, that's all. You need a different tool for the job...

Jul 13, 2008 9:07 AM in response to Jim Frazier

(How do you do that indented highlighting?)


Yes, I know that --- and I thought that RMX was doing the samething.
--->And if it is a MIDI file, the "drumset" sound loaded has all the elements (kick, snare, TOMS, etc...) to create a fill or groove variance without the actual soundbank changing.


I'm not blaming RMX --- I understand what it does and it's terrific at it. But it doesn't do what I want
--->But I'd encourage you not to blame RMX.


I don't understand your reference to Discrete Drums....that looks like drum sample collection. But getting good drum samples is not my problem. PLAYING the **** things is the issue 🙂

Jul 13, 2008 10:26 AM in response to dhjdhj

You can accomplish what you are trying to do.. Create a RMX module in Logic's arrange page. Make 7 more copies of the same module.. These will correspond to RMX's 8 tracks..

Go to RMX, on track one, select a groove, now drag that midi file to the first instance on Logic's arrange page.. Copy and paste the 1 bar midi file to the appropriate measures you need, 1-4, 9-11, etc.

On track 2 of RMX, select another groove, drag that into the 2nd instance of Logic's arrange page, place that at the appropriate measure, and copy to following measures, 5-6, 12-14, etc.

On track3 of RMX, select a 'groove fill (tom roll etc)'. Drag that into Logics arrange page track 3, and place at appropriate measure.. measure 8, 16, 32, etc.

Using this method you will have 8 different grooves available to use.. If you look in Logic's "LIST" mode you will see that each midi groove file you dragged from RMX, has a different midi channel.

This method makes creating a drum track easy, because it is very graphic when looking at Arrange page.. I usually 'color' the sections, so I know that a green one is a snare roll, a red one is a straight beat, a blue one is an alternate beat etc.. Once you've decided on your drum arrangement, you can bounce all the RMX midi chunks to one track. (make sure that the RMX is assigned to ALL channels)

If you need more than 8 grooves, create a 2nd RMX module in Logic, and do the above again.

Jul 13, 2008 11:41 AM in response to Mark Styles

But that's the problem --- I want each set of those measures to be slightly different. So for example, that groove fill (tom roll) you suggested on track 3 needs to be slightly different each time. I realize that there's some automation capability that gives you the ability to create some variations and I'm looking at that. But, for example, I can easily imagine having 4 or 5 completely different styles of fills in a song, as well as numerous variations on patterns for different parts of different verses. Having to put each of these on a separate track seems very awkward.

--->Copy and paste the 1 bar midi file to the appropriate measures you need, 1-4, 9-11, etc.

Jul 13, 2008 12:50 PM in response to dhjdhj

dhjdhj,

Discrete Drums is a Drum Loop collection. Loops of live drum performances, arranged in a construction type of approach. verse, chorus, verse 2, chorus, bridge, etc... with various fill options. It also has individual samples, to use separately, or in combination with the loops.

Back to RMX for a moment...Have you experimented editing the MIDI data to create the variances you want? I do this a lot... go into the piano roll editor, and start moving the MIDI events to other notes within the loop. You can get some wonderful variations this way, and can create entirely new grooves from the loop slices available to you.

Also, look into RMX'S CHAOS function. This is a built in "randomizer", that produces some excellent variations and fills from the existing loop.

Jul 13, 2008 1:58 PM in response to dhjdhj

If you haven't already, check out the tutorial videos on Spectrasonics' site. There is one where they get RMX to do exactly what you are looking for. I never use RMX for this type of app (I'm into the drag 'n' drop thing), but there's a different mode you can run that will allow you to automate the different grooves. You'd basically roll through the song and trigger the different section from a midi controller while recording the note info into a track in Logic.

Jul 13, 2008 2:25 PM in response to rico3.5

Thanks....I did actually download 4 of them after I created the original post and so have a better understanding of what RMX is doing. I certainly could use automation to approximate the results I want but it still doesn't seem like the right approach, at least for what I am trying to do (I recognize that others find it terrific).

For example, I created a new track into which I put a 2 beat fill at the end of a verse but I can't figure out how to now add a SINGLE crash at the end of it.

Jul 13, 2008 2:38 PM in response to dhjdhj

dhjdhj wrote:


For example, I created a new track into which I put a 2 beat fill at the end of a verse but I can't figure out how to now add a SINGLE crash at the end of it.


It's a common practice to have stuff like cymbals, crash, ride, hats, ect... sitting on another MIDI channel, to add accents to a live drum loop.

And example would be an 8 bar groove played with no crashes. Simply adding a crash sample on bars 1 and 5, etc, or sneaking in an open then closed hat sample, would allow you to create variances of the main groove, without using up another MIDI channel with a slightly varied loop.

EDIT, I see rico already suggested that as I was typing.

I'm sure many of us here who do program drums (and I don't do it much anymore though) will use various software instruments, along with loops, to achieve the desired result.

One things is for sure... I never got the whole drum performance from one plug-in. It took many MIDi channels, as well as audio tracks, to create the final illusion.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Anyone using Stylus RMX with Logic? Do you understand "grooves"?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.