Turn Shades off. Use 1.8 gamma. Calibration software should prompt you to set brightness and provide visual feedback when it's properly adjusted. I've already indicated where my brightness is set. The calibrator needs to read and display the actual luminosity of
your display. When prompted to lower it, using the keyboard command.
Luminosity/brightness is only one variable within the color calibration equation. Arguably it's the least important. I say this because it is relative to the amount of ambient light which likely changes over the course of the day. Get the hue and saturation corrected.
I just read this comment about
Shades on VersionTracker:
"I've been using Shades for a while, and like it a lot. But when I made a screen profile resently (with Color Eyes Display Pro) I noticed that changing profiles in Screen Preferences acted strange. I then turned Shades off, and the newly made profile made the screen turn green!
I made a new profile with Shades turned off, and things work now.
So if you don't care about profiling your screen, then Shades is very nice. But if you calibrate your screen, then I think it's a no good, at least for the time being."