Should I purchase a Best Buy warranty ($400) with a MacBook

I plan on purchasing a new MacBook from Best Buy. Best Buy offers a 3 year warranty for $400. It covers basically everything including accidental damage and surge protection. If they can't fix it, they will replace it. Does anyone have experience with Best Buy warranties? Is it worth an extra $400? With the warranty it will bring the price of my new MacBook up to $1700. YIKES!!!!User uploaded file

Posted on Nov 8, 2008 4:32 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Nov 10, 2008 1:54 PM

Just to clarify my earlier point. As a former Best Buy employee who was periodically pressured by department managers to sell service plans at any cost, I can assure you that they are generally a rip-off. (Don't even get me started on the ways BB expects its employees to act like commissioned salespeople without actually giving them commissions) Best Buy pushes the extended warranties, because they are the single biggest way the company can improve its margins. By and large, service plans are all profit. After they're sold, the company does EVERYTHING it can to avoid making good on claims. When I worked in the Geek Squad, I was explicitly told to give customers a hard time: to delay service, try to convince the customer that everything was fine, or to obfuscate as much as possible. Turn around times are terrible, and there is little, if any, support for the end user at the corporate level. Granted, these are one man's observations while working at two stores here in southern Arizona. Still, I would urge you to stick with Applecare and avoid Best Buy's plans like the plague...unless you are exceedingly tenacious and don't mind waiting for multiple weeks/months for repairs/service. True, Applecare doesn't cover accidental damage, but my experience has always been that there is some wiggle room. Plus, Apple's customer support is second to none, in my opinion, and the value of the phone support has inestimable value. Caveat emptor wth BB.
24 replies

Nov 8, 2008 10:39 PM in response to xray scatter

I have had (and used) AppleCare on several iBooks and PowerBooks. It has been worth it on every one. When there was a problem, they would send a shipping carton overnight, and I would typically be without the computer for a week (once even less!). My guess is that if Best Buy were to fix a similar problem, it would take longer. Of course, AppleCare doesn't cover abuse of the computer, and Best Buy costs more. Another advantage of AppleCare is that you can get phone support, which is occasionally good enough to avoid even having to send the computer in.

Personally, next to FireWire, I think AppleCare on notebook computers is Apple at its best :0)

Nov 9, 2008 7:18 PM in response to sueinvenice

sueinvenice wrote:
how do the sellers on amazon offer applecare for less than mac stores?


That's a good question - and the answer is that the list price of Applecare, which is what Apple sells it for, is way more than Apple charges dealers for it.

One step more in the deductive chain and you'll realize that AppleCare is overpriced. But it's probably still a good idea, at least on laptops, since Apple parts and repairs are even MORE overpriced.

Nov 8, 2008 11:05 AM in response to xray scatter

Just to clarify...

My understanding of the Best Buy warranty is that it's almost like insurance. So if you require support from Apple once your complimentary coverage has expired (1-year) you'll have to go through Best Buy for everything, as in Apple's eyes the machine is out-of-warranty.

With that being said, AppleCare does not cover your machine if you break it (drop it, smash it, spill your coffee, etc.). So if you find yourself to be clumsy, perhaps the peace of mind of $400 vs. $1300 makes sense. Quite frankly, if you don't keep an open container of liquid near your machine when you're using it, you've already saved yourself a lot of "worry."

I've never purchased a 3rd party hardware warranty, I've always gotten the manufacturer's one (if ever). But from my experience, the 3rd party ones required extra work to file and process a claim when the product would fall outside the manufacturer's window and inside their window.

Nov 8, 2008 11:38 AM in response to xray scatter

When it comes to Apple, the only thing that the Best Buy Service plan has on regular Apple Warranty + Apple Care is that the Best Buy Warranty has protection against accidents. If you aren't accident prone, go with Apple Care (which should only run you around $300 dollars for three years of coverage and Phone Support.

However if you were buying a PC I'd say go for it. With the experience I've had with warranty repairs of other companies, I'd get Best Buy, They have a lemon policy where if it breaks down three times they will often issue credit towards a new system. My wife and I did purchase this service plan with our most recent windows PC laptop purchase, but I'd only ever by Applecare for an apple computer, though.

Apple however is really good about honoring their warranty as long as there is no evidence of abuse about, that's the only time you will generally have problems with Apple service. In the case of an Apple product I would much rather get Apple care and then look into your home owners insurance has riders cover none manufacturer faults.

If you do get the Best Buy warranty you'll be going to Best Buy if you have any problems, not Apple, though the Apple warranty would still be in affect for the first year, you wouldn't want to waste one of your years with Best Buy.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Should I purchase a Best Buy warranty ($400) with a MacBook

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.