Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

New Macbook/Macbook Pro unibody aluminum edges too sharp

I don't know if others have experienced this, but the Macbook/Macbook Pro unibody has very sharp edges. This isn't a problem most of the time, like when sitting at a desk. But when sitting on a couch with the laptop on my lap, these sharp edges really cut at the wrists, which is quite uncomfortable, even leaving lines on the skin. I think it would be better if Apple had beveled the edges a bit to round them slightly. I found myself thinking about filing them myself or maybe having the edges beveled professionally. I wonder if any others have had a similar experience. I may inquire about this at the local Apple store.

Macbook/Macbook Pro (new unibody), Mac OS X (10.5.6)

Posted on Jan 10, 2009 9:19 PM

Reply
185 replies

Mar 19, 2009 8:25 AM in response to rdhuberman

It is truly unfortunate that 90% of the comments, both good and bad, have been deleted by a moderator.

There had been many excellent solutions offered by people like eww, Travis, gpotts, and others that would have served other concerned users well.

Instead, someone has done a hack job to this thread leaving it very misleading to new customers.

Apr 12, 2009 12:50 AM in response to jpomerleau

Every user has different sized hands and will use different sets of posture. However, I have used various macbooks for years now and they have never been uncomfortable to use in almost any position....until now.

My macbook pro unibody is really really hurting the palm / heel of my hand. I need to rest it straddling the edge of the macbook whenever I am using the trackpad. This is because of the positioning of the pad in combination with the overly sharp edges. Terrible ergonomics!

I use my laptop a lot and my hand is getting really bruised in the same spot. It is to the point now where I am avoiding getting work done.

It is important for everyone experiencing problems to voice their complaints so that Apple will eventually get the message.

Yes I can get some sort of gadget or chunk of material to rest my palm but I have never had to do this on any other laptop (pc or mac). I certainly never would have expected this from a $2000 laptop from a company that (formally) prides itself on ergonomics and usability.

Apr 17, 2009 4:17 PM in response to tthiel1

"edges too sharp" yes they are machined to a sharp edge. Also it has to do with the placement of the touchpad relative to the front edge of the computer. No matter what I do (and no matter what your hand size) you have to rest the heel of your hand diagonally across this edge if you are going to use your index finger to track and your thumb to click.

The only way it does not hurt is if I keep my hand raised above the trackpad and do not rest it. This gets tiring quickly and is not necessary on any other computers I use or have used.

Apr 17, 2009 4:25 PM in response to intellijel

if you are going to use your index finger to track and your thumb to click.


This is the problem, primarily. You do not need to use your thumb to click anymore. I found that posture to be quite painful anyway. It is much easier if you turn on tap to click, and rest your hand on the surface that the MBP sits on. Then rest your thumb up against the vertical part of the MBP (by the thumb scoop for the lid) and use your index finger to track, tap, and click (if you really insist of clicking physically).

I know old habits die hard, but this different way is really much more comfortable in my opinion. I never liked old trackpads with physical buttons.

--Travis

Apr 20, 2009 1:57 PM in response to jpomerleau

I just got a new MacBook Pro 17" at work, and I'm here because I have spent hours online googling what to do about the sharp edge of the wrist rest. I simply can't believe the design, nor the rationale for it. No other laptops I've ever used have this drawback, nor have been this uncomfortable to use. The comments about posture--I don't buy it. I'm a professional writer and magazine publisher and know how to sit and how to type and what good posture is and all that--but the fact remains that to reach the keyboard when sitting with the laptop on a table-height surface, or on your lap, the wrists and lower arms end up brushing against the sharp edge simply due the distance from the edge to the keys. I'd have to be standing over the keyboard or elevated in my chair by three pillow to be at an angle where the edge didn't chafe. The very fact that this area of the keyboard is a "wrist rest" implies that the hands will not always be floating above the keys, and resting them invariably brings them in contact with the (yes, very sharp) edge. I've been searching for a solution and unless I find one soon the laptop is going back. I spend too much time on it to be in pain while using it. The 'legs' that were posted are a nice idea when it's on a table, but those won't work on your lap. Any links to products or tips to adapt the case are appreciated, but for $3000 this is craziness.

Apr 20, 2009 7:38 PM in response to pbandmacs

If the edges of the MBP are as problematical for many other people as they are for you, rest assured that some enterprising third party will soon offer an add-on product to remedy the defect in Apple's design. And if that doesn't happen, you can draw your own conclusion about how many users are seriously harmed or hindered by the MBP's edges.

New Macbook/Macbook Pro unibody aluminum edges too sharp

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.