Drive won't read any dvd-ejects it automatically after spinning some time

The SuperDrive on my MBP has stopped recognizing/reading any blank DVD media (and many recorded DVDs, including movie discs). It spins for some time with a noise and then ejects it out. The same media works fine in my wife's Sony Vaio laptop.


There was a thread on this previously, but Apple has closed it:


http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1295681


I know Apple won't own up to the problem, so has anyone found a solution?


----------


Drive details:


HL-DT-ST DVDRW GSA-S10N:


Model: HL-DT-ST DVDRW GSA-S10N
Revision: AP09
Serial Number: K0***********928
Detachable Drive: No
Protocol: ATAPI
Unit Number: 0
Socket Type: Internal
Low Power Polling: Yes
Power Off: Yes


<Personal Information Edited by Host>

MacBook Pro - Intel Duo Core 2.4GHz, Mac OS X (10.5.6), null

Posted on Feb 24, 2009 8:14 PM

Reply
1,164 replies

Aug 12, 2009 5:21 PM in response to Gryff

You can add me to the list.

HL-DT-ST DVDRW GSA-S10N:

Firmware Revision: AP09
Interconnect: ATAPI
Burn Support: Yes (Apple Shipping Drive)
Cache: 2048 KB
Reads DVD: Yes
CD-Write: -R, -RW
DVD-Write: -R, -R DL, -RW, +R, +R DL, +RW
Write Strategies: CD-TAO, CD-SAO, CD-Raw, DVD-DAO
Media: Insert media and refresh to show available burn speeds

I insert disk makes some robot noises, and then ejects, It use to work then it was just BLANK DVD and CDRs it wouldn’t read now its everything.


This is really a problem for me now because I cant use the system restore disk that came with the computer. I am having some hard drive issues and need to use the repair mode that you can use when you boot off the disk, but now I cant even load the disk!

I am going to see a genius today, I hope he can help me, I have tried every thing you guys have suggested with the exception of the firmware flash.

My computer is just over a year old and there is no reason this should be happening...

Aug 13, 2009 12:30 AM in response to Gryff

If your Superdrive (or any other optical drive) ejects the disc without properly mounting it, you're pretty much looking at a hardware (OPU) failure. Only after the drive recognizes the disc, is it mounted in the Operating System.

My Superdrive was replaced a short while ago because of the exact same problem; a deteriorating OPU. At first, it would not recognize blank DVD+-R discs, then blank CD-R, finally pressed CD/DVD's. At that time, I sent it in again under AppleCare and had it replaced.

From the symptoms you describe, the Mac OS software updates are not to blame here.

Greetings,
Ed.

Message was edited by: Ed Voncken (tyops)

Aug 13, 2009 1:16 PM in response to Gryff

I just saw a comment to an article on TUAW that mentioned this issue. http://www.tuaw.com/2009/08/07/a-weekend-with-firewire/2

I've never dropped my laptop before... But I have the same issue with CDs on
my MBP. I found a workaround... The problem seems to be the motor gives out during low power
spins, so when the cd being read or prepped for writing slows down, I tap somewhat hard above the
cd drive with my finger. This goes on for about 30 seconds off and on. But it works everytime.

Aug 13, 2009 7:40 PM in response to barkplunk

I've watched this thread grow and grow since I added my name to the list just 5 months ago. I've been a Mac user since the early 80s and it's shameful that APPLE has simply chosen to ignore this issue. I have to agree with others, I don't see this as a software issue - and I've tried all the suggestions - cleaning disks, compressed air, etc. etc. all to no avail. (Have not tapped yet - more on that in a moment).

The new PC commercials must be making some inroads. The comments like "it seems you're paying a lot for the brand" and the buyer walks out of the store with a Dell, or IBM, or whatever. Macs do cost more but I've always felt they were worth it.

Once there was a huge software gap between the platforms but no more, anything I can do on my Mac I can do on a PC. I still don't like the evil Darkside but geeez, come on Apple - you're making it harder and harder for us to stick with you. Too often rather than doing what's right and stepping up to the problem, Apple makes you struggle along in the dark.

Case in point. I just had a 5th gen ipod go bad. I was about to send it in for a $100 paid repair when another forum member found that Apple had recently admitted the problem I experienced was a technical issue and they are replacing those iPods at no charge... BUT ONLY IF YOU ARE SMART ENOUGH, PERISISTENT ENOUGH OR JUST LUCKY ENOUGH TO FIND OUT ABOUT THE PROGRAM. At least the auto industry makes it known publicly when there's a service or recall issue. As a registered owner of one of those model iPods wouldn't it have been nice to have received a notice from Apple alerting me to the issue and telling me of the problem resolution? But rather than do that Apple seems happy to let us consumers waddle along in the dark, throw out the bad iPod apparently sure in the knowledge that we'll go back to the well and blindly buy another. I'm sure someone at Apple is thinking right now, no big deal, he'll just come back and buy one of the new MacBook models. Well for me, the blinders are about to come off.

Now that I've vented, fyi this is the 2nd drive to go bad in my MBP - I'm off in search of my hammer. As my dear father always said, if something isn't working, just give it a good WHACK!

Aug 13, 2009 8:48 PM in response to coyote moon

coyote moon wrote:

Case in point. I just had a 5th gen ipod go bad. I was about to send it in for a $100 paid repair when another forum member found that Apple had recently admitted the problem I experienced was a technical issue and they are replacing those iPods at no charge... BUT ONLY IF YOU ARE SMART ENOUGH, PERISISTENT ENOUGH OR JUST LUCKY ENOUGH TO FIND OUT ABOUT THE PROGRAM. At least the auto industry makes it known publicly when there's a service or recall issue. As a registered owner of one of those model iPods wouldn't it have been nice to have received a notice from Apple alerting me to the issue and telling me of the problem resolution? But rather than do that Apple seems happy to let us consumers waddle along in the dark, throw out the bad iPod apparently sure in the knowledge that we'll go back to the well and blindly buy another. I'm sure someone at Apple is thinking right now, no big deal, he'll just come back and buy one of the new MacBook models. Well for me, the blinders are about to come off.


Can you point us to more information on this iPod issue?

Aug 14, 2009 6:27 AM in response to Gryff

My iPod quit working, that is to say it no longer made any sound. I could select playlists, songs, etc. and the countdown timer would run but there was no audio. I found that if I pushed with my thumbs on the lower corners - sort of as if I were text messaging, the sound came back, though often with great static. I posted a note about it here on the forums while searching and planing to just pay to have it repaired. Fortunately another forum member, who saw my post and was having the same problem found the information below and sent it to me.

My point though is that as a registered owner of the model iPod with an identified problem, Apple did nothing to make me aware of this and I could easily have spent $100 for a repair, or far more for a replacement unit, when I was entitled to a free replacement because of a defect. (I did follow these instructions and did receive a free replacement as did the gentleman who sent these instructions to me.)

Here's the info and source as it was sent to me......

As many people have seem to have reached dead ends after calling Customer Support (myself included!) I thought I would share the plan of attack that worked for me:

1. Call the Customer Support for iPod number: 1-800-275-2273. I just kept hitting 0 so I didn't have to listen to the automated iPod diagnosing junk.

2. Tell the first person you speak with that your iPod no longer has any sound. Explain that when you apply pressure to the lower right hand corner of the iPod the sound will return, but when pressure is released it goes away again. Tell them it is a manufacturing defect and that you would like to speak with a Representative who can refer your case to a Product Specialist. (If they tell you your product is no longer under warranty, let them know it does not matter in this case, and to please go ahead and transfer you).

3. The Customer Care Representative. Tell them everything you told the first person. MAKE SURE YOU TELL THEM ABOUT THE PRESSURE ON THE CORNER ISSUE! This is apparently key to them understanding/diagnosing the problem. If they say they have never heard of it being an issue, tell them it was only recently (within the past month or so) noted by Apple, and that the Product Specialist/Engineers should know exactly what the deal is.

4. At this point, they should be telling you that they see it is in fact a problem, and that there is something that can be done! If they are still giving you the run-around, let them know it has definitely been noted by Apple and that you would like the matter to be handled properly! If you need to, ask them to refer you someone else, and to refer you to the Product Specialist regardless of whether or not they are informed on the issue.

5. Hopefully by now you should have been either referred to the Product Specialists, or the Representative will have talked to them for you. The woman I spoke with just put me on hold for a few minutes while talking to them, and returned to tell me that I didn't even have to speak with them myself, and to just give her my address and E-Mail. She said someone would be contacting me shortly and that I should receive a new iPod within a week or so. She apologized for my treatment before and was very polite and helpful.

I found these instructions & testimonials at:

http://forums.macnn.com/103/ipod-iphone-and-apple-tv/351485/no-sound-ipod/3/

Aug 18, 2009 10:21 AM in response to Gryff

I'm sorry...I was under the impression that we paid a premium for Mac products because they just work? But again, it seems to be another problem with my new MBP that I've found another thread on that contains hundreds of Mac users with identical problems.

I guess that's Apple's advertising at its finest. They got me to buy one thinking it was somehow better...in the end, it's turning out to be worse than my 6 year old PC.

/rant

Add me to the list of those with the problem.

Aug 18, 2009 10:52 AM in response to Stangs55

Too bad for coyotemoon, whose latest post was blown away by a salvo of "moderation". (Too late... I read it...) I agree with him, though. His post may have been deleted, but the rumor is rumbling louder and louder: in France, where I live (hey, nobody's perfect...), the press is starting to criticize Apple's lack of interest in iPods and iPhones having their screen cracking and even pelting the user's face with small pieces of glass.

I'm a Mac user and I'm proud of it, but I can't condone that kind of behavior. As a commercial venture, Apple has a duty toward its clients. It must make sure the products it sells are reliable and not dangerous.

We're not asking for much. R-E-S-P-E-C-T... Want me to sing it...?

Message was edited by: Didier Caizergues

Aug 18, 2009 3:53 PM in response to OneCatFamily

More and more are adding their names to this list...

I would not have such a problem with this issue if it were in a desktop tower where it is easy (and less in cost) to swap out the DVD drive. But this is a Mac Book Pro Laptop which the DVD burner is very difficult to swap out. Maybe Apple is looking for addition income for all the repairs that are needed.

Reminds me off all the banks making a fortune off late fees, overdraft fees, and loan origination fees (53% of bank profits)...

Aug 24, 2009 7:50 PM in response to Gryff

Count me in as another success story! Yay!

Drive was getting picky as to what it would mount & burn errors beat successful messages. Drive was goin' south.

Stuffed in the nozzle of the compressed air and gave a good pass over everything. Then for good measure I took the vacuum cleaner to the port. Yeah the vacuum cleaner.
Worked like a charm & burning disc #10 as I write this.

So the simplest no tech fix ever & it saved me whatever the r&r might have cost - applecare died in june. Great discussion this solved my problem!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Drive won't read any dvd-ejects it automatically after spinning some time

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.