Does iPhone 3G have the features of the iPod Touch?

Question

Level 1

8 points

Does iPhone 3G have the features of the iPod Touch?

Hi there, I am planning to get either an iphone 3g or an ipod touch. I am unsure of which one to get. I love the features of the new ipod touch, and does the iPhone 3G have all of the features of the new ipod touch? Where can I find this info? I know 3Gs is the newer one but I can get an iPhone 3G for free if I sign up for a phone company in my area. I don't care about text messaging or that stuff. A phone that I can use to call and receive calls will do. I do however love the features.

Now, I want to know if the iphone 3G has the features the the new ipod touch (2nd gen) has.

Windows Vista

Posted on Jul 4, 2009 7:57 PM

Reply

Answer 1

dmiannay

Level 3

869 points

Jul 4, 2009 8:01 PM in response to tml81

Here's a [thread|http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=9596814&tstart=0] that discusses this subject.

Reply

Answer 2

tml81 Author

Level 1

8 points

Jul 4, 2009 8:05 PM in response to tml81

Thanks for the link. I will continue to go through the thread. But from you experience, the iPhone 3G does have the features of the ipod touch and is better than the ipod touch (2nd generation)?

This is the iPhone 3G we're talking here right? Not the new 3Gs?

Reply

Answer 3

tml81 Author

Level 1

8 points

Jul 4, 2009 8:37 PM in response to tml81

Can someone please answer my question? I assume a lot of you have the iPhone 3G so does it have the features of the ipod touch? and is it better?

Reply

Answer 4

roaminggnome

Level 10

106,395 points

Jul 4, 2009 8:39 PM in response to tml81

http://www.apple.com/ipodtouch/features/

http://www.apple.com/iphone/iphone-3g/

Reply

Answer 5

Jul 4, 2009 9:42 PM in response to tml81

I have both, so let me try.

Better is not a word I would use. They are both good in their own way, but the iPhone has more functions (phone and SMS obviously) including GPS for location services, and GPRS/EDGE for connectivity when not near wifi as well as camera.

The iPod touch is thinner and lighter; and I also think it is better on battery life, but that may be in part because several of the apps unavailable to the touch are somewhat processor or graphics intensive: I have to charge the iPhone usually once a day, while I may get a couple of days out of the iPod touch.

Depending on where you are (and I note you show you are in Canada - Rogers) the cost of the iPhone may be higher with service charges, while this can be offset as these are monthly: you have to buy the touch outright.

If you want the device for music and videos, plus synchronisation of contacts and calendars along with a few games, the touch might suffice. However, it is not a stripped down iPhone and the iPhone is not a beefed up iPod touch. They do have separate identities and uses.

Reply

Answer 6

tml81 Author

Level 1

8 points

Jul 5, 2009 7:40 AM in response to tml81

Thanks, does the iphone 3G have the accelerometer too like the ipod touch 2nd gen? Reason I am still interested in the iphone still is because one I am getting it free and second, I am getting a really good deal with the service charges as per my needs. Like I said, if the iphone can do what the ipod touch can then I really don't need to spend $300 on the ipod touch. I don't care about SMS or anything, just some of the features and call/receive calls will do for me.

I was reading a review between the iphone 3G and the iphone 3Gs -

http://www.engadget.com/2009/06/08/iphone-3g-vs-iphone-3g-s-the-tale-of-the-tape /

In the wireless connectivity part, it says the iPhone 3G has 3.6mbs HSDPA - does this mean that I can use the wifi at only that rate? Since I have a 16mbps internet connection, but I can only surf at 3.6mbps?

Reply

Answer 7

Jul 5, 2009 8:14 AM in response to tml81

The iPod touch does have the accelerometers like the iPhone. If you are getting the iPhone under such favourable terms, you would almost certainly do as well to go that route rather than take the touch (I had a touch for about a year then was lent the iPhone).

As for speeds, yes the iPhone (and touch) are limited, but you are not going to be using them at home only. EDGE and GPRS and 3G are not as fast as wifi, but the device is limited: it works fairly well keeping me up to date with email and other data.

As for SMS, I hear that N. America doe snot use this as much: really useful and quick (and cheap) way to keep in touch.

Reply

Answer 8

Daiya

Level 4

1,666 points

Jul 5, 2009 10:37 AM in response to tml81

it says the iPhone 3G has 3.6mbs HSDPA - does this mean that I can use the wifi at only that rate? Since I have a 16mbps internet connection, but I can only surf at 3.6mbps?

That's not what it means. 3.6mbs HSDPA refers to the speed of the cellular data network--it has a radio that will handle that speed network. This doesn't have anything to do with the speed you will get over wi-fi, which operates totally separately from the cellular data network.

Reply

Answer 9

JoeZinVA

Level 2

431 points

Jul 5, 2009 11:29 AM in response to tml81

To explain it better, both the second generation iPod Touch and "iPhone 3GS" are the same as far as everything including Nike+ except the phone parts.

Both do music
Both do offline games (3G/3GS are needed for online games unless you have a paid hotspot account)
Both have Nike+ (second gen touch and 3GS if I recall the talks)

However, 3G/3GS have the GPS, phone, abilities to play online games anywhere, camera, video recorder, etc. and the iPod Touch avoids all that. Oh and the 3D Graphics Accelerators.

Reply