Defeat Logic's auto CC1 reset?

Just CC1?

You can always stop it chasing in settings/midi/chase and then turning off control change 0-15

As for completely defeating it in the clicks and ports transformer window, well you can filter changes coming in, but that won't affect what happens when you stop and start logic.

Try checking 'No Reset' in the inspector.

I think you should go here: *Logic Pro>Preferences>MIDI>Reset Messages*
!http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2444/3939980425_989dd0d1a6.jpg!

Regards, Erik.

mrl2 wrote:
The "No Reset" checkbox SHOULD address this, but it seems broken

Make sure that in +Preferences > Audio > Reset+ the 'Control 1' box is NOT checked.

For me, under this condition 'No Reset' seems to work as expected.

Photofinish! 🙂
O, wait a minute... that's four different options to uncheck...?
Prefs>Audio>Reset uncheck *Control 1 to zero* (why is this setting in the Audio prefs??)
*Prefs>MIDI>Reset Messages* (2: cc1 unchecked and 'send Used Instruments Settings on Reset' unchecked?)
and
*Project Settings>MIDI>Chase* (uncheck 'send full MIDI reset before chasing'?)

Erik,

AFAIK, the reset messages of your picture are relevant only for external MIDI.

You could always just draw in CC1 val 90 with the list editor on the first note of the first bar in your channel.

bill borez wrote:
You could always just draw in CC1 val 90 with the list editor on the first note of the first bar in your channel.

But that doesn't help if you want to stop and continue playback somewhere on the track.

Eriksimon wrote:
Prefs>Audio>Reset uncheck *Control 1 to zero* (why is this setting in the Audio prefs??)

Because it refers to audio instruments I guess.

Anyway, it's obviously a BIG MESS.

Fred B wrote:
Erik,

AFAIK, the reset messages of your picture are relevant only for external MIDI.

My first impulse was a foreheadslap - I had heard that before, your afaik was also my afaik. Then I opened up the LP9 pdf, and it became less clear:

p. 649
To turn off stuck notes
Do one of the following:
Click the lower MIDI Activity display section in the Transportbar.
Click the Stop button twice in rapid succession.
In both cases, reset messages are sent, as defined in Logic Pro > Preferences > >MIDI > Reset Messages.

No word that this only works for external sound.

P 1284:
*MIDI Reset Message Preferences*
The preferences in this pane are only included for compatibility with older >MIDI hardware. Logic Pro handles MIDI reset messages automatically and intelligently, so you should generally make sure that all of these options are unselected. (This the >default.)

This does not explain where they are sent, and though there is mention of 'older hardware', it doesn't state explicitly that it is not sent to Software Instruments.

All selected checkboxes will send a reset message, for the selected controller type, to all MIDI outputs.

Does that include internal/virtual outputs? Rewire? IAC-bus? Environment?

This reset message is sent on cycle jumps and when playback begins, but the use of these options shouldn’t be necessary.

Why not? I'ld really like a MIDI signal flow chart in the manual for these sort of settings...

Anyway, I shall now mess with it, because all this is theory plus manual, practice should clarify more... 😉

regards, Erik.

Eriksimon wrote:
Anyway, I shall now mess with it, because all this is theory plus manual, practice should clarify more... 😉

Good luck!

BTW, if you want to see what messages are actually sent into a plugin you may use the MIDI monitor which is available in Kontakt as utility script.