While I don't recall the issues your iBook had, regarding the trading stock
value in this circumstance, depending on what that problem was with it
could make it worth more or less. Aside from a partial trade, where you
get rid of the iBook and get this iMac G4 800 (17") with superdrive; the
software set is not really worth anything since all the official installer discs
for the OS X, the MS Office, and others, are not included in the deal.
And, if the computer is running 10.5, that is a marginal installation in the
800MHz 17" iMac G4; the super drive and other hardware specs can
manage iLife's apps in the '06 iLife vintage, but not later. Tiger is OK in
that machine and works wonderfully. (I had one, nearly perfect with all
the accessories, and Airport card installed; gave it to a friend with the
software installers and backup of free installer downloads on DVD, etc)
A local business (in larger town north of me) had four iMac G4s including
the 1.25GHz USB2.0 iMac with 17" display, for $150. each; probably had
a few for a little more money, but said they'd been checked over and were
original, other than maybe added RAM. All had a fresh install of OS X, and
worked well. They'd upgraded to a later model; that was via craigslist.
Of course, I have a few iMac G4 17" 1.25GHz models & a mid-2005 iBook.
And I have an unused Mac OS X 10.5 retail installer; so would be looking
for something to put the newer OS version into; not an iMac G4.
$350. may be a bit steep for the iMac G4 you cite; if it had like new original
accessories, keyboard, mouse, speakers, Airport card, extra cables ie:
USB, ethernet, phone modem, firewire, and original power cable; factory
software on original disc media, and a retail copy of the newer OS X in it...
Then it would be worth $350. with valid licensed OS X software.
The added Office and anything without a retail installer with password
put into the computer is worthless. You can't install it, & it is illegal. If
the seller worked in a retail store and knows software, he should know.
Per your iBook G4, I forget what the issues were; you could probably
get it repaired for about $60. labor plus parts, if not a logic board; from
a known-good Apple portable expert such as wegenermedia.com.
If the iMac G4 seller had a 1.25GHz model with wireless card, it may
be worth $350. including all the original accessories. In a retail market,
the model could be priced higher; if expecting a limited guarantee.
The older USB1.1 iMac G4 800 with 17" display, & original Airport card,
with SuperDrive, 1024MB RAM, speakers, keyboard, mouse; in great
shape? Deducting something for the iBook (status: questioned) you
shouldn't pay over $200. for it; not without licensed OS X discs included.
But that's just my opinion. There is still a demand for the iBook G4,
though if it has some serious issue it may be OK trading stock as-is
and I would only fix it if I were expecting to get it going for under $150.
through wegenermedia. They offer fixed computers. sS figure what
any extras are worth you can separate from your iBook, in a trade.
The RAM upgrade, if removable, the wireless card, etc. If you decided
to get another iBook some of the extra upgrades may fit an identical one.
Anyway, that's two topics; plus the value issues.
I'm on the fence, on this one. You could get a
tower computer with dual processors for $350.
Maybe even a PM G4 dual 1.42 like new. I read
of people getting an air-cooled PM G5 tower for a
few hundred dollars (dual 2GHz) with LCD panel.
{And some repaired & warranted MacBook Core2Duo
machines are out there - comparatively inexpensive.
Ones that can run 10.5 and maybe 10.6. Early Intel-
based Macs shipped with Tiger 10.4. And some of
them don't like Snow Leopard, so values vary there.}
Without a thorough service tech report on that iMac G4's status, he may
want a bit too much for it. Not seeing it run, and not performing any
third party tech utility tests on it (diskwarrior, techtool, etc) it is a question.
My upgrade path would have to include a computer
that can support an OS X later than Leopard, if new;
or run Leopard without any issues. That's fairly basic.
With three G4s running Tiger 10.4.11, that is OK. But
it isn't really great when the future for Tiger is closed.
No security updates, no java updates. Looking at 10.5.
If by now, you've seen and bought the iMac G4 800MHz
17" with superdrive, you could have done worse. Or it
could have been money toward a refurbished MacBook
from the online Apple Store; or a wegenermedia iBook.
Good luck & happy computing! 🙂