White Eye in pictures taken with iPhone 4's flash

Has anyone else had this problem? iPhoto will not let me correct this as it does red eye. Does anyone know the best way to remove the white eye?

iPhone 4, iOS 4

Posted on Jul 6, 2010 7:43 AM

Reply
39 replies

Dec 19, 2011 7:43 PM in response to The.Todd

The red-eye fixer in iOS5's built-in photo editor does a decent job of killing the white eye. If you have iPhoto '11 It then transfers the edited and original photos too, so you can "revert to original" in iPhoto... but if you do, you can't re-apply the "white eye" fix within iPhoto.


It's not perfect--if the picture's a bit motion-blurry, or the white eye blends into the skin around the eyes, the black filler will splotch outside the eye, or fill in the white center which also looks weird. It's not obvious when this happens because you can only zoom in so far on the iPhone screen, but once seen in iPhoto with a large screen the results can be grotesque and worse than the zombie white eye.


For this reason, I avoid using flash whenever possible. Thankfully the 4S has a pretty decent low-light sensor, but if Apple's serious about taking on the entry-level P&S camera market they need to replace the LED with a xenon flash (which don't work when shooting video), and accept the hit on the battery; or come out with something even better.

Dec 30, 2011 9:58 PM in response to The.Todd

It's just awful. Makes the flash completely useless for people shots. Can I please have terrible red-eye back? iPhoto totally fixes that so easily. This white eye will not be fixed the same way because the color is blown out of people's eyes. I can't believe I never saw this mentioned in reviews. I think the problem is the way the flash fires, which should be fixable in software (I imagine). It's as though they've come up with a method of avoiding red-eye only to replace it with something that ruins every photo instead. So frustrating.

Dec 31, 2011 7:19 AM in response to jefffromhealdsburg

They didn't come up with a method for avoiding red-eye per se--it's because the iPhone 4/4S uses an LED flash instead of a xenon flash used in some other camera phones, which takes more battery and space, and can't be used when taking video.


White LEDs don't have the natural spectrum that traditional flash bulbs have, so instead of red that's reflected back in the eyes it's a pure white.


Correcting that in the iPhone's photo software works only about 75% of the time, the remaining 25% have problems I mentioned earlier.

Dec 31, 2011 9:19 AM in response to pepper62

Agreed--almost all the camera reviews tested static scenes, very few with people and even those few were usually outside without flash.


The 4S camera has replaced my (4-year old) P&S Canon camera because its low-light sensor is pretty darn good for a camera phone, and I have it on my all the time. I just make sure to take several shots so at least one should be without motion blur. Some blur is obvious, others you can't tell until you import and see them on a bigger screen.


Oh, and only use the virtual button for low-light shots; pressing the physical button causes just enough motion that blurring happens in low light, when the shutter is held open just a bit longer. Especially if the button's under a case.

Dec 31, 2011 1:58 PM in response to pepper62

I meant when taking shots without flash. Flash means the shutter doesn't have to be held open as long, but leads to white eye. No flash = no white eyes, but even with the 4S' improved low-light image sensor you have to hold the iPhone still for a fraction of a second longer. You'd think this would be easy, but no one I've handed my phone to in order to take a picture with me in it has managed to get this right the first couple times.


Obviously the subjects of the flash-less picture must stay pretty still too--another reason I take several shots in rapid succession, they never know when exactly these are since there's no flash to tell them when the shots are, but they'll hold fairly still until I indicate I'm done.


I can still take flash-free shots in as dark a place as a bar. A nightclub though, I need the flash... and the built-in software for attempting to fixing the white eyes.

Mar 5, 2012 12:40 AM in response to The.Todd

In relation to Russlunn's post regarding Retinoblastoma, he is very wise to consult his doctor, my wife and I had been viewing photos taken on her iPhone 4 of our 14 month old son and indeed his eyes were white instead of the usual "red eye" taken with a normal flash. Symtoms of Retinoblastoma are a white glow in the eye, often seen in photographs taken with a flash, instaed of the typical "red eye" from the flash the pupil may appear white or distorted. From this post I discovered the iPhone 4 flash is LED,I normally bounce the flash on my other camera so this was the first time I had even seen red or white eye in photos of my son. I took a series of photos with a normal point and shoot digital camera and was relieved to see red-eye (not white glow) in both his eyes, which indicates normal healthy eyes. It is best to have the room dim, stand around 4 feet from the subject, turn the red eye reduction funtion on the inbuilt flash to off ( or force the flash to on) and zoom so the whole face is in the view finder. My wife and I had a restless night's sleep until our son woke so we could examine his eyes!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

White Eye in pictures taken with iPhone 4's flash

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.