There are 2 mic related problems, I know because I have faced them both.
a. Non-speaker mode others cannot hear
b. Speaker mode other cannot hear 🙂 simple.
Bought the first iPhone 4 on Saturday, never realized that the speaker mode workes since all weekend I was out. Took it in on Monday and the "genius" replaced my phone and was out within 20 mins.
No reasons given, it was from a Black "replacement" box.
Wednesday, the reverse issue, when non-speaker mode works on phone calls, people I call cannot hear what I say on the speaker mode.
Again, took it in, no reasons given, got a replacement.
The "genius" underplayed that fact that I asked whether there were others that were facing this issue, he said "No sir, yours is the only unfortunate case we have witnessed."
I also asked if I am doing anything different than others, he mentioned nothing.
I have a feeling this is some hardware issue that they are aware of and are trying to cover.
Here are the facts for both the times.
1. updated to 4.0.2.
2. downloaded a bunch of free apps.