Recording Latency in Logic Pro X - recording electric guitar, once I finish a take I listen back and everything is ahead of the beat.

I'm recording electric guitar direct-input. Once I finish a take I listen back and everything has been nudged back to be ahead of the beat (consistently). Low Latency Mode is turned on. In Preferences > Audio > Devices my recording delay is set to 0. Above that it says Resulting Latency: 51.1ms Roundtrip 24.9ms Output.

Any advice on how to solve this latency issue?

Thank you!