How to shuffle music in genres

Do you want to shuffle music within a specific genre?

If I misunderstood what you are trying to do, please clarify.

If I understand it correctly, it is very easy.

Say you want to hear some Classical music of yours (or Rock, or whatever).

Just create a Smart Playlist with genre Classical and shuffle away!

Well, after further check, it does work directly with the "Genre" added on the left bar as I indicated yesterday... if the "Shuffle" mode is defined "per song" in the "Command" menu, and not "per album" as it was defined for me yesterday... and except for my "Pop/Rock" genre with which it just doesn't work (too many songs? or some corrupt information somewhere?).

Thanks for the tip, but I still have a problem: the smart playlist gets created without problem, but if I try playing it, in normal or shuffle mode, Music just crashes immediately! (my genre has 5261 songs).

I really wish Apple would just bring back the "shuffle all" for genres!!!

By the way, if you hover over "Library" on the left bar, you can add "Genre" (in addition to "Recently added", "Artists"), which is good... but still without possibility to play it all in shuffle mode. Or at least I didn't manage to make it.

... and with another Genre with just 14 songs, Music doesn't crash... but even when clicking on "Shuffle", it plays the songs in the "non-shuffled" order...

I don’t know why it’s crashing and not playing it shuffled. It worked for me in the few times I tried.