Greyed out favorite icons

Hi ParrisWeitzman.

In general, the Apple Store is a better solution for repairs and such than for this kind of software issue. If the issue persists, you may want to reach out directly to Apple Support. If it is an issue that requires a Genius, they can also help you make an appointment.

Contact - Official Apple Support

Especially this time of year, if you do decide to head to the Apple Store, make sure you make an appointment. Going without one might be a bit of a Brilliant Mistake.

Cheers.

Hello ParrisWeitzman and welcome to Apple Support Communities.

I see you are having an issue with the icons for favorite web sites that appear when you open a fresh browser window showing as gray-scale rather than in color. Some users have reported that simply rebooting the Mac clears this issue.

If the issue persists after rebooting the Mac, move on to booting into safe mode.

Use safe mode to isolate issues with your Mac - Apple Support

After booting into safe mode, reboot again normally and test. If the issue persists, set up a new admin account for testing.

How to test an issue in another user account on your Mac - Apple Support

Cheers.

Hi ParrisWeitzman.

Great Elvis Costello reference.

The key here is going to be having cleared the Safari history. Just like the small icon in the address bar, the info for these logos will come from the sites or services themselves. You may see the color info repopulate as you visit the actual sites.

Cheers.

Did you sign into every one of your Google icons besides signing into Google?