Mail account unable to connect when on hotspot

Hi - starting recently (probably with Catalina), whenever using my iPhone's hotspot, one of my Mac's Mail accounts (pop gmail) is unable to connect to the server (even after trying to re-enter the username and password multiple times). As soon as I switch to another wifi, it automatically connects just fine. Any thoughts? Thanks!

MacBook Pro 15", macOS 10.15

Posted on Jan 5, 2020 8:11 AM

Reply
9 replies

Jan 8, 2020 10:34 PM in response to BobTheFisherman

BobTheFisherman wrote:
Because when connecting using webmail you are connecting directly to the email provider's servers where they can control spam attempts. Connecting through hotspots or third party networks bypasses this spam control system. So email providers/ISPs often restrict sending of email from other than their own systems.


So the following is actually expected behavior?


ALLOWED: any wifi --> webmail

ALLOWED: any wifi --> POP client such as macOS Mail

ALLOWED: iphone hotspot --> webmail

BLOCKED : iphone hotspot --> POP client such as macOS Mail

Jan 9, 2020 7:40 AM in response to jszrules


jszrules wrote:


BobTheFisherman wrote:
Because when connecting using webmail you are connecting directly to the email provider's servers where they can control spam attempts. Connecting through hotspots or third party networks bypasses this spam control system. So email providers/ISPs often restrict sending of email from other than their own systems.

So the following is actually expected behavior?

ALLOWED: any wifi --> webmail (correct)
ALLOWED: any wifi --> POP client such as macOS Mail (Maybe, for receiving)
ALLOWED: iphone hotspot --> webmail (correct)
BLOCKED : iphone hotspot --> POP client such as macOS Mail (Maybe. for sending)

No, that is not what I described. The issue isn't the POP client the issue is only sending of email. You send email using an SMTP server. If I own a SMTP email server and you have an account I allow you to send email using my server as long as you are signed into your account on my server and you are sending from you@myserver address. If you are connected to the

Internet using some other access such as a hotspot and trying to send email using my SMTP server I or the owner of the hotspot may restrict you because you are trying to use another provider's service to send an email using my server not using their service. Spammers like doing this because it helps to protect their servers from being labeled as the origination of spam emails.

Jan 5, 2020 8:23 AM in response to jszrules




jszrules wrote:

Hi - starting recently (probably with Catalina), whenever using my iPhone's hotspot, one of my Mac's Mail accounts (pop gmail) is unable to connect to the server (even after trying to re-enter the username and password multiple times). As soon as I switch to another wifi, it automatically connects just fine. Any thoughts? Thanks!



This is a good question for the provider of your POP account. Call their Support.


https://support.google.com/mail/answer/7104828?hl=en


If you can’t send email on your Mac

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204075

Jan 6, 2020 7:14 AM in response to jszrules

jszrules wrote:

Thanks for the replies, but still a bit confused. I am still able to login to the webmail version of gmail when connected to hotspot, so not sure why I wouldn't be able to connect via POP. Is anyone else experiencing this issue with gmail POP when using their iPhone hotspot for connectivity instead of wifi?

Because when connecting using webmail you are connecting directly to the email provider's servers where they can control spam attempts. Connecting through hotspots or third party networks bypasses this spam control system. So email providers/ISPs often restrict sending of email from other than their own systems.

Jan 9, 2020 1:10 PM in response to BobTheFisherman

thanks for clarifying. a few points:

1) My issue isn't just sending emails from macOS Mail when connected to the hotspot. It's incoming, as well. Mail immediately switches that account to "offline" and doesn't recognize the login info to the POP Gmail account. Other email accounts on Mail work just fine.

2) It used to work just fine. I used to have no problem receiving and sending mail from macOS Mail regardless of whether i was on hotspot, wifi, ethernet, whatever...

3) Something still smells fishy here. iPhone hotspots I'd imagine should be considered "safe". What makes traditional wifi any different in terms of security from the iPhone cellular hotspot?

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Mail account unable to connect when on hotspot

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.