Aspect ratio does not match while using identical monitors
Problem
I have two of the exact same external monitors connected to my Macbook Pro, via two different thunderbolt 3 ports. When both monitors are connected, only one displays the correct aspect ratio for full screen viewing, the other has black bars surrounding the image. I can get both monitors to display full-screen aspect ratios by connecting each independently to my Mac, but cannot get them BOTH to work at the same time. Any suggestions?
Mac Info
Macbook Pro 13-inch, 2018, Four Thunderbolt 3 Ports
Graphics Intel Iris Plus Graphics 655 1536 MB
Monitor Info
Brand: Sceptre
Model: E248W-19203R
Active Screen Size: 23.8” Diagonal Viewable
Native Resolution: 1920 x 1080
Refresh Rate: 75Hz
Aspect Ratio: 16:9
Response Time: 16 ms
Color Depth: 16.7M (6-bit Hi-FRC)
Contrast Ratio: 3,000:1
Dynamic Contrast Ratio: 1,000,000:1
Brightness: (cd/m²) 250 cd/m2
Viewing Angle: 178˚ (Horizontal) / 178˚ (Vertical)
Backlight Life: 50,000+ Hours
MacBook Pro 13”, macOS 10.14