You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Sabrent NVMe SSD :: Catalina panics and reboots with these SSDs...

I've just migrated to a new 8-core i9 MBP 16 2019 (32GB).

Latest Catalina 10.15.5. The "old" one was a 6-core MBP 15 2018 (16GB), with "inflated batteries" (incredible for such a premium machine, but... this is another story).


I was using an external NVMe SSD 1TB from Samsung (970 EVO): never had a problem. But... full.

So I've bought a Sabrent 2TB (Rocket with TLC chips, pretty fast on paper).


I did try to migrate MBP 2018 to 2019 using time machine on this new Sabrent SSD.

I had to reapeat the backup creation for about 6-8 times, 'cos the old MBP did creash / panic and reboot a lot of times during the backup creation (always with a IOSCSI error, so disk related).


Then even the new MBP 16, using the same SSD, did crash as well many times during the restore... so that at the end I did use a different old Samsung SSD drive to finalise the migration.


Before returning the Sabrent to Amazon I did try changing the case/enclosure (both NVMe USB 3.1 Gen 2 compatible) but I keep on suffering the same exact problem.

Then I even tried to copy a large quantity of data (about 500GB) from my NAS to the Sabrent, but I kept having the same problem: after some time the SSD "detached" from the Mac and, after some minutes more of timeout, the machine crashed and rebooted.

Consider I even tried to use some dry ice to keep the SSD aluminium enclosure cold (thinking maybe the high volume of transferred data caused too much heat). No results.


OK, so I thought to have received a defective SSD and sent it back to Amazon, ordering a new one, exactly the same model.


And today I tried it up the new one. Curious to know? Same exact problem.

These SSD cannot sustain an high traffic on Catalina: after some minutes they detach and crash the system.

Even more... something that I cannot understand, after the crash I cannot anymore detach/reconnect the SSD to the system: Catalina does not see the drive. Even changing the USB port. Even changing the case/controller.

But it is possible to connect it to my iPad Pro.


Bottom line: is this an operating system problem or an SSD problem? Or... is it a compatibility problem between Catalina and THIS Sabrent model? (the Samsung EVO 970 and 860 that I have do work).


Thanks in advance











MacBook Pro 16″, macOS 10.15

Posted on Jun 8, 2020 6:53 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jun 14, 2020 4:25 AM

I confirm: received the UGreen enclosure with AMS2362 a couple of days ago.

And, up to now, it works! Finally...

(I did not change any other "parameter": same Catalina, Sabrent NVMe, cable and software used)


Similar questions

2 replies

Jun 9, 2020 10:20 AM in response to jlm70

Meanwhile I've found out in another thread that the JMicron JMS583 ver.A0 enclosure controller may prove less compatible with Catalina + Sabrent, and in general have stability problems: and this is the controller I've both in my two Orico and Adwit NVMe enclosures.


The Asmedia ASM2362 controller - included in other cases, such as the UGreen - seems to be far more stable.

I've ordered one, and I'll test it in short...


As for the USB 3.1 Gen 2 enclosures, at the moment the JMicron chipset is the most diffused. The other ones are the ASMedia ASM2362 and the Realtek RTL9210.

JMicron seems aware of the stability problem and is releasing a new version (ver.A2?) of its JMS583 controller.



Sabrent NVMe SSD :: Catalina panics and reboots with these SSDs...

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.